Alright, here are my preliminary puts/takes. I may adjust these after the box arrives and I get a good look at some of these sticks. Please be kind.
Take: #1 Opus X Robusto Put: LFD Outlaw 2008 blend
Take: #29 Tatuaje Frank Put: AF Between the Lines
Take: #52 H. Upmann Mag 46 Put: PSD4
Take: #54 My Father lancero Put: LFD Factory Press III
1) I honestly don't know anything about the Outlaw stick - at all. Never smoked it, never seen one, only briefly heard of it. Only thing I could find was
HERE and appears to be $11/stick normally and $9.90/stick "on sale" (anyone know how long this "sale" has been running?) From what you're saying, there's only 1,200 sticks in existence. If those figures are correct and not exaggerated, it definitely adds a rarity factor. What I don't quite understand is why such a dwindling supply of said stick would be on sale. Anyone care to elaborate on the stick? Seems to be like a Casa Fuente cigar - "rare" except regionally? Anyone?
2) Good. As many people said, both are relatively hard to find, MSRP is just about equal. BTL is a limited release twice a year, Frank was a "one time" shabang. If this was 3 years from now, I'd condifently say no to the trade. However, speaking of the current situation, looks good.
3) Good. I did some research and checked five trusted retailers, all of which I have done business with. Came out with an average of $7.60ish for a PSD4 and $7.75ish for a Mag 46. I'm not going to split hairs about two common smokes that are $0.15 apart. Other passer input is appreciated!
4) Good. As a side note, the LFD III is pretty tasty.
Edit: Formatting/typo.