All right... with the pass expected to hit within the next day or two, I'll get my P/T up for approval.
Takes:
3. WOAM
5. VSG Tres Mystique
17. Padron 1926 - No. 35
32. PAM Imperial
Puts:
34. La Aurora Preferido Cameroon Robusto
35. Fuente Don Carlos #3 from the "30 Year Celebration 1975-2005 Collection" seen
here.
36. Macanudo Vintage 1997 III
37. Graycliff Professionale PGX
So, I thought that I would take this opportunity to explain what I go through when I check P's and T's; it is the same thing I do when I am checking to see if what I am putting into a pass is comparable to what I plan on taking. This is not a personal attack; I am just trying to explain where I am coming from and hopefully add some useful information for current and future pass participants. :thumbs:
First, since this is a 1 for 1 pass, I really need to know which cigars you are trading for which cigars in the pass. I can conjecture that you are proposing P's/T's in the order listed, but it is best to be clear. And I tried to do a little juggling to see if they would all match up, but was unsuccessful.
I typically take several online sites and compare prices to come up with an average to gauge a cigar's value by. The sites I used are listed below in my example. I always look at the box price and divide by the number of cigars in the box if it is available. I also look at the cigar's rarity, which is more difficult to gauge, but should be considered. Here is what I came up with for your P's and T's:
Cigar Websites Used for Reference
a) PipesAndCigars.com
b) AtlanticCigar.com
c) CigarsInternational.com
d) RegencyCigars.com
e) Holts.com
f) CigarPass MSRP references
Proposed P's and T's
Takes:
3. WOAM
5. VSG Tres Mystique
17. Padron 1926 - No. 35
32. PAM Imperial
Puts:
34. La Aurora Preferido Cameroon Robusto
35. Fuente Don Carlos #3 from the "30 Year Celebration
1975-2005 Collection" seen here.
36. Macanudo Vintage 1997 III
37. Graycliff Professionale PGX
Averages from Websites
3= a)X b)X c)X d)X e)$7.36+ f)$7.35+ :
$7.35 rare
5= a)$7.50 b)$10.53 c)X d)$8 e)$8 f)$7.50 :
$8.30
17= a)$13 b)$10 c)X d)$10 e)X f)$10 :
$10.75
32= a)$17 b)$14 c)X d)$14 e)X f)$14 :
$14.75
34= a)$8 b)$6 c)$12 d)X e)$7 f)X :
$8.25
35= a)$7+ b)$6.12+ c)$6.96+ d)$7.76+ e)$7.76+ f)$7.75+ :
$7.23 very rare
36= a)$7 b)X c)$6.25 d)X e)$6.85 f)X :
$6.70
37= a)$14.40 b)$10.80 c)$13.40 d)X e)X f)X :
$12.87
Then I look to see if they are close in price and rarity. If a cigar is rare, it is usually valued more than what is listed as the typical price. For instance, the Don Carlos #3 from the anniversary collection is valued more than what a regular Don Carlos #3.
So, you should be able to see where I think your P's and T's could use a little work. LMK what you think and how you would like to proceed, or if you have any questions.
Thanks,
- C