Here are my Puts and Takes-
Take ~for~ Put
12 - Opus X BBMF Maduro from Opus 22 '08 ~for~ 48- Hoyo de Monterrey Particulares Edicion Limitada 2000
22 - Cohiba Sig VI '03 – unbanded ~for~ 49- AVO 22 Euro Edition (from canister #241 of 2000)
29 - Monte # 2 '06 ~for~ 50- Punch Punch from 2006
51- Partagas Series D #4 from 2007
I am not right on the money for the Hoyo, but I am pretty confident they where close to the Opus 22 value when they sold fresh, but I could be wrong, so do not etch it in stone. Either way they are expensive now. I have seen them go for $60-$80 a piece if you can find them.
I am going to make one more pass through the box once this is finalized and I will let you know on the VSG .
Jim
12 - Opus X BBMF Maduro from Opus 22 '08 ~for~ 48- Hoyo de Monterrey Particulares Edicion Limitada 2000 - Still can't find MSRP and I paid $50 for the BBMF, but I like the rarity and im sure the MSRP matches. - GOOD
22 - Cohiba Sig VI '03 – unbanded ~for~ 49- AVO 22 Euro Edition (from canister #241 of 2000) - GOOD
29 - Monte # 2 '06 ~for~ 50- Punch Punch from 2006 Punch Punch - Found a source where Monte #2 is $11.08 and Punch Punch is $9.32 - Big gap and rarity is not really a factor here.. Let's discuss this furthur or put a different stick in. - NO GOOD (For Now)
51- Partagas Series D #4 from 2007 - THANKS !![/b
If you want to match the prices with that site you need to look at the punch punch also..Punch Punch - $7.92 ea.
Still does not work out.
I am happy to delete the monte/punch if that is what we want to do . I was trying to place sticks in here that I think are worth the time smoking. IMHO the Punch Punch is a smoke that not many mention, but is a great smoke. Anyway I agree with the others. For the record the 2000 Hoyo is even more rare than the 2001 and will simply blow your mind, to quote someone else.
Jim
Jim, I'm leaning towards modifying the P/T's for this stick and I appreciate Ed and Andy stepping up with some great information, but were almost at a $2 mismatch and it is very debatable which is a better smoke between the Monte and Punch...
You can either change or let's here what others have to say about it.
Thanks,
Brian