• Hi Guest - Sign up now for Secret Santa 2024!
    Click here to sign up!
  • Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

The CP Make-a-Wish PIF Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wilkey in general I would agree with you but if you aren't getting bites on a mag46 or a monte edmundo my inclination would be you need to start asking for cigars from a different country.
 
Agreed. There is no disagreement here. Your specific observation is spot on, I was generalizing to a broader case but we are both on the same page.

Wilkey
 
Thanks for letting me know. How long do you think i should wait till i get involved in pases like these. Also
im liking the avatar. (I really dont like the Pirates but there not that bad) :)
 
Wilkey in general I would agree with you but if you aren't getting bites on a mag46 or a monte edmundo my inclination would be you need to start asking for cigars from a different country.

This was my feeling as well. The Cohiba Sig VI and Lanceros are always hard, but, like you said, no hits on a Mag46 or Monte Edmundo suggests something... :whistling:
 
Thanks for letting me know. How long do you think i should wait till i get involved in pases like these. Also
im liking the avatar. (I really dont like the Pirates but there not that bad) :)
Get in where you fit in. Read the rules and if you can grant a wish then make one.

Brian
 
so are you guys trying to say that because im not a novice cigar smoker, i have to "dumb-down" my wishes and ask for NC's because im new? Im sure that people are just passing over me because im new (to this site only).. which is WRONG..

ive changed my list to a less conservative list, and that was passed over (and u know why)..

what would changing it again solve?
 
so are you guys trying to say that because im not a novice cigar smoker, i have to "dumb-down" my wishes and ask for NC's because im new? Im sure that people are just passing over me because im new (to this site only).. which is WRONG..

ive changed my list to a less conservative list, and that was passed over (and u know why)..

what would changing it again solve?

See the words in red at the top of this page?

Linky


Also read this (Newbieness) :

Linky

This may be part of the issue. :cool:

Oh and welcome to CP ! :thumbs:
 
so are you guys trying to say that because im not a novice cigar smoker, i have to "dumb-down" my wishes and ask for NC's because im new? Im sure that people are just passing over me because im new (to this site only).. which is WRONG..

ive changed my list to a less conservative list, and that was passed over (and u know why)..

what would changing it again solve?


I am not the expert on this as some are, but I will try to answer your question. It is common courtesy to change your requests after some length of time (not specified) so that we can keep this moving. If you look back through the history of this thread you will see it goes pretty fast for the most part. There are a few exceptions (me included), but it is a fun, fast paced "game". If your wish is not being granted in over 72 hours, I think it might behoove you to switch it up a bit. And no I am not saying you need to make it "dumbed down", but jsut changed maybe a bit. It is curious that some of those have not gotten a hit, but then again you have 11 posts and have just joined. I would try some good NC's and maybe that would help. In the end it is up to you, but after 3 days of nothing I think it would be better for everyone to switch it up a bit. this is just my .02 however.

Don
 
I'll get BigRon on one of his wishes, let's get this thing moving again. Ron, PM me your addy.

I wish for a Partagas Culebra. If this doesn't fly by this evening, then I'll take whatever someone wants to send.
 
I'll get BigRon on one of his wishes, let's get this thing moving again. Ron, PM me your addy.

I wish for a Partagas Culebra. If this doesn't fly by this evening, then I'll take whatever someone wants to send.


Hey Greg

Got you on the Culebra. Will be in the mail today.

I pass my wish to Jim........ Stepthirteen

Bob
 
First I have to say that I am undeniably humbled by this act of generosity. A longtime member just comes out of no where and grants a wish and then passes it along to someone in an act of complete uselfishness, wow!!! Thanks again Bob! I would like-

Punch Punch with some age
Monte #2 with some age
Or send me your all time fav

Thanks again Bob the generosity is humbling!!

Jim
 
First I have to say that I am undeniably humbled by this act of generosity. A longtime member just comes out of no where and grants a wish and then passes it along to someone in an act of complete uselfishness, wow!!! Thanks again Bob! I would like-

Punch Punch with some age
Monte #2 with some age
Or send me your all time fav

Thanks again Bob the generosity is humbling!!

Jim


Well I wouldn't say long time member. Never the less.....Enjoy

Bob
 
I'll get BigRon on one of his wishes, let's get this thing moving again. Ron, PM me your addy.

I wish for a Partagas Culebra. If this doesn't fly by this evening, then I'll take whatever someone wants to send.


Hey Greg

Got you on the Culebra. Will be in the mail today.

I pass my wish to Jim........ Stepthirteen

Bob

Thank you Bob!! I am REALLY looking forward to it! Much appreciated!
 
I'll get BigRon on one of his wishes, let's get this thing moving again. Ron, PM me your addy.

I wish for a Partagas Culebra. If this doesn't fly by this evening, then I'll take whatever someone wants to send.


Hey Greg

Got you on the Culebra. Will be in the mail today.

I pass my wish to Jim........ Stepthirteen

Bob

Thank you Bob!! I am REALLY looking forward to it! Much appreciated!

Enjoy Greg.........

Bob
 
so are you guys trying to say that because im not a novice cigar smoker, i have to "dumb-down" my wishes and ask for NC's because im new? Im sure that people are just passing over me because im new (to this site only).. which is WRONG..

ive changed my list to a less conservative list, and that was passed over (and u know why)..

what would changing it again solve?


I am not the expert on this as some are, but I will try to answer your question. It is common courtesy to change your requests after some length of time (not specified) so that we can keep this moving. If you look back through the history of this thread you will see it goes pretty fast for the most part. There are a few exceptions (me included), but it is a fun, fast paced "game". If your wish is not being granted in over 72 hours, I think it might behoove you to switch it up a bit. And no I am not saying you need to make it "dumbed down", but jsut changed maybe a bit. It is curious that some of those have not gotten a hit, but then again you have 11 posts and have just joined. I would try some good NC's and maybe that would help. In the end it is up to you, but after 3 days of nothing I think it would be better for everyone to switch it up a bit. this is just my .02 however.

Don

So there's not a 3 month waiting period to join this pass ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top