Necrobumping this one! In the past week or two I've watched Reacher (Amazon), Hawkeye (Disney+), and just finished Cobra Kai S4 (Netflix) last night. All were phenomenal.
Let's talk Reacher: THIS is what live-action Jack Reacher should have been all along. It took me an episode or two to really be sold on Alan Ritchson's acting but, man, they nailed this series. You will never truly please a book-purist, and I'm admittedly on the fringes of that camp. Making concessions for dramatizing a novel for the screen is necessary, and I can handle that, but if you are tacking an iconic character and series, you need to at least make an effort (looking at you, American Assassin). Amazon kept pretty true to the source material of Killing Floor, and hit all the high points they needed to hit in order to make it a Jack Reacher story, rather than just a rando generic story line where the main character happens to have a famous name (looking at you, Jack Ryan). Ritchson portrays it much the way Cruise did in the two films, but with a bit more playfulness that took a little bit to come around to. The elephant in the room with the Tom Cruise movies was obviously his physical stature. So, Amazon got an actual elephant to play Reacher this time. Jack Reacher's physical size is a character unto itself, which was why Tom Cruise was not the right guy for the part. He portrayed him well, but Reacher's pro-wrestler appearance is half of what makes him Reacher.
The other three main characters were excellently cast, as well. Roscoe, Finlay, and Neagley were all pretty much how I remember picturing them. I think. I believed in the acting, in any case (Neagley was perfect, dammit). My only complaint, really, was that they seemed to have phoned in the final episode as far as the writing goes. Even though this is where the biggest differences from the novel occurred, they were still mostly believable, but the sequence writing was just formulaic and lacked imagination. The acting, again, was great; not their fault.
Yeah, I'm gushing. I'm a huge Jack Reacher fan, so I was incredibly excited to see the first previews for this show a few months ago. I don't think a better final product could have been produced that both reaches and attracts a mass audience, as well as satisfies the purists. I remember reading Killing Floor (the first in the series, and I believe Lee Child's first attempt at writing) and being unsure about it. Child found his stride after a few books, and I can't wait to see what Reacher S2 brings. My only disappointment is that Willa Fitzgerald and Malcolm Goodwin will not return for the next season. I hope that the show runners cast just as well for the supporting characters next time around.
I can't recommend the series highly enough if you are a Jack Reacher fan, and I think you'd probably enjoy the series even if you've never read a single one of the books.