vortex
"A billion Eddie Barzoons jogging into the future
- Joined
- May 5, 2006
- Messages
- 5,510
I just finished an old sci-fi, "Beyond the Horizon" by Robert Heinlein(1942). I've been reading some authors with "new eyes" that are due to age and experience.
For starters, I never really noticed that his dialog is terrible. Dialog is one of the most difficult aspects of writing but Bobby's is really bad. I think one reason I had ignored it was that Heinlein was always about his thematic ideas, which were unique and refreshing.
The theme of this was no exception. It's set in a utopia. Remember, this was published just as the horrors of Hitler's utopic ideals were widely known. Eugenics, formerly embraced by American Establishment, got a serious black eye. So it was interesting on it's own and from a historical perspective.
Secondly, everyone is packing in this utopia! I hadn't ever read of one like that. A whole set of customs he created to make it work made it fairly feasible. People are damn polite in that type of society. Kind of like the old Westerns.
If you can stomach the dialog, I thought it was an inventive and instructive story vis-a-vis present day hysteria and insanity.
For starters, I never really noticed that his dialog is terrible. Dialog is one of the most difficult aspects of writing but Bobby's is really bad. I think one reason I had ignored it was that Heinlein was always about his thematic ideas, which were unique and refreshing.
The theme of this was no exception. It's set in a utopia. Remember, this was published just as the horrors of Hitler's utopic ideals were widely known. Eugenics, formerly embraced by American Establishment, got a serious black eye. So it was interesting on it's own and from a historical perspective.
Secondly, everyone is packing in this utopia! I hadn't ever read of one like that. A whole set of customs he created to make it work made it fairly feasible. People are damn polite in that type of society. Kind of like the old Westerns.
If you can stomach the dialog, I thought it was an inventive and instructive story vis-a-vis present day hysteria and insanity.