• Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Cigar Aficionado Top 25 and a pretty cool thread jack.

{tpc} said:
I’d like to try the 10, but I don’t think I’d be worth a damn as a reviewer. But I’m sure I can rank anything from 1-10 lol.

And I thought it was a well known thing that the ratings in CA’s top 25 have almost always been bought and paid for.

I used to subscribe, as I found it a fun read, and a decent value as a subscription. Not sure what they cost now. I have a box of old editions somewhere in the basement.
Click to expand...
Jump in brother!

I'm not good at "reviewing" cigars but I certainly know when I like one. So all we have to do is categorize how we liked it; construction, flavor, etc.
 
SKYDIVNEKD said:
I'll just harken back to the day the Onyx seegar was top rated. Well, let's just say the Onxy was a TURD and not worth the time or money spent, acquiring it. If we're gonna rank "subjectively", then it is what it is. CA will continue to "sell" their subjectivity to the highest bidder. After-all, it is what they do. How can a man argue that the monkey testicle sweat he's tasting in the Oliva isn't better than the rhino hoof rot he's getting from the Tatuaje?! Who am I to say which is better?

Yea, I'm in a mood not worthy of posting, so I'll cease. Just saying, the wheel of flavors is truly subjective and if you can make(steal) money to find it, why not(if you have no morals). Yup, back to my cocktail!

Floyd T
Click to expand...
Floyd, I love it when you post while you are in a mood!

There is also the issue of circumstance. I have had some awesome cigars once, that I was never able to replicate. It all had to do with the people, the food, the day, Etc.
 
@CgarDan Dan, tell us the way you prefer to be paid so we can set it up if we don't already have it. I already have you on Venmo if that's okay?
 
CigarStone said:
Jump in brother!

I'm not good at "reviewing" cigars but I certainly know when I like one. So all we have to do is categorize how we liked it; construction, flavor, etc.
Click to expand...
Thanks for the encouragement. I’ll just follow along and maybe if I can find the cigars being done locally, and have the expendable for it, I’ll pick one up at that time.

It’s a great idea though!
 
So.... who is going to be #1? Any guesses?

Cigar Aficionado

Browse the largest collection of cigar ratings and reviews as well as the latest coverage on cigars, Cuba, gambling, golf, beer, spirits, and more.
www.cigaraficionado.com

I say AJ get's it with that New World Dorado...
 
cohibasurfer said:
So.... who is going to be #1? Any guesses?

Cigar Aficionado

Browse the largest collection of cigar ratings and reviews as well as the latest coverage on cigars, Cuba, gambling, golf, beer, spirits, and more.
www.cigaraficionado.com

I say AJ get's it with that New World Dorado...
Click to expand...
Michael, if you read my post you would already know

My Father Opulencia
 
CgarDan said:
Looking great. 12 people signed up

1) @CigarStone
2) @Pugman1943
3) @CBoukal
4) @cabaiguan juan
5) @lherzolite
6) @Gavin
7) @JoeMO
8) @smellysell
9) @Nate1977
10) @H. Vachon
11) @drunkfish3
12) @cohibasurfer
Click to expand...
Probably need 3 more or to dump 2 so you can buy fivers right??
@Thoughts where you at brother
@TexasTraveler - Where you at brother
@Tall Paul - Where you at brother
@Onlycubans - Didn't you want to branch out and try some NC's
@bfreebern - Didn't you say you would join as long as someone tells you how amazing your reviews are?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top