This is what I see as the updated list...
Stick # Cigar PUT TAKE
n/a 98 Upmann #4 petite corona Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a '97 Bolivar Inmensa Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a '98 Partagas Series du Conniseur #2 cabinet Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a ~'98 Custom rolled/handmade Partagas Culebra Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a '01 El Rey del Mundo Choix Supreme cabinet Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a '03 Juan Lopez #1 Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a '01 Ramon Allones corona cabinet Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a '98 Saint Luis Rey petite corona cabinet Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a ~'99 Toboada Salamones (bought in '99, could have been rolled in '98) Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a '05 Montecristo #4 petite corona Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a '00 La Gloria Cubana Medaille d'oro #2 Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a ? Custom rolled Cohiba blend salamones Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a recent Fuente Work of Art maduro Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a '05 release Fuente 858 sungrown Matt R. Devin Cole
n/a 1 pair of Fuente Between the Lines black cap opposing wrapped "twins" Matt R. Devin Cole
1 H. Upmann Petit Palatino '78 Devin Cole CoventryCat86
2 Bolivar Gold Medal '04 Devin Cole Tone-NY
3 Partagas Piramide LE '00 Devin Cole Castaway
4 Partagas Salomones Espanola '95 ("Salomones I") Devin Cole NorCalCigarLover
5 ERDM Panetelas Largas '78 Devin Cole BlindedByScience
6 Cohiba Lancero '98 Devin Cole Castaway
7 Ramon Allones Specially Selected '94 Devin Cole Castaway
8 La Escepcion Longo '86 Devin Cole Swissy
9 Cohiba 30 Aniversario '96 Devin Cole NorCalCigarLover
10 Montecristo Petit Corona No.4 Special Selection (Queens Jubilee) '02 Devin Cole CoventryCat86
11 Dunhill Atado '84 Devin Cole CoventryCat86
12 Partagas 155 Aniversario "109" '00 Devin Cole strayvector
13 Padron Millennium Maduro '00 Devin Cole Bfreebern
14 OR 858 Sungrown '00 Devin Cole Tone-NY
15 OR Ashton VSG Robusto "R" '97 Devin Cole Bfreebern
16 Opus X Petit Lancero '98 Devin Cole marcsheldon
17 OR A? No. 50 '00 Devin Cole Tone-NY
18 OR A? No.77 '01 Devin Cole NorCalCigarLover
19 Behike second or fake Matt R. NorCalCigarLover
20 Behike second or fake Matt R. preembargo
21 SP Sanchos ‘03 CoventryCat86 preembargo
22 SLR Serie A ‘06 CoventryCat86 BlindedByScience
23 Tatuaje Churchill CoventryCat86
24 Punch PC ‘99 CoventryCat86 Castaway
25 SC El Principe ‘05 CoventryCat86 strayvector
26 Monte #2 ‘02 CoventryCat86 Castaway
27 RA PC ‘01 CoventryCat86 BlincedByScience
28 Davidoff No.1, el Laguito, 90 Tone-NY preembargo
29 Don Carlos, Edicion de Anniversario, Robusto, 06 Tone-NY
30 Don Carlos, Edicion de Anniversario, Double Robusto, 06 Tone-NY
31 Don Carlos, Edicion de Anniversario, Toro, 06 Tone-NY
32 Opus X Reserva D'Chateau 2006 Castaway
33 God of Fire Robusto 2005 Castaway
34 SLR "A" 2003 Castaway
35 Anejo #49 2005 Castaway
36 Diamond Crown Max Stanford's 90th Castaway marcsheldon
37 Partagas Series P #2 2005 Castaway
38 Bolivar Belicoso Fino 2005 Castaway
39 Davidoff No.2 ‘89 preembargo marcsheldon
40 Montecristo A ‘03 preembargo
41 Montecristo EL DC ‘01 preembargo strayvector
42 WOAM (age unknown but very yellow cello) preembargo
43 Fuente Between the Lines 2004 marcsheldon
44 Padron Millenium '00 marcsheldon NorCalCigarLover
45 Bolivar Corona Extra '98 marcsheldon Swissy
46 Cohiba Reserve Millenium '00 marcsheldon strayvector
47 PAN Piramide Single Band '99 Bfreebern
48 Opus DC '97 Bfreebern
49 ERDM Choix Supreme '98 Bfreebern NorCalCigarLover
50 Cohiba Siglo V '99 Bfreebern
51 H. Upmann Conn #1 '98 Bfreebern BlindedByScience
52 Custom Rolled Diadema Bfreebern
53. Davidoff Diademas Finas NorCalCigarLover
54. BTL NorCalCigarLover
55. Avo 22 NorCalCigarLover
56. FFOX Royal 8 NorCalCigarLover
57. Punch Black Prince '00 NorCalCigarLover Swissy
58. Cohiba Sublime EL 2005 (fake) from the same source NorCalCigarLover
59. Cohiba Seleccion Reserva Robusto NorCalCigarLover Swissy
60. Cohiba Double Corona EL 2003 NorCalCigarLover
61. Taboada Torpedo '06 NorCalCigarLover
62. Cohiba Piramides EL 2001 NorCalCigarLover strayvector
63. Tang Comissioned Upmann Monarch (ECA NOV 02) strayvector
64. Partagas Lusitania (FPG NOSU) strayvector
65. Cohiba Siglo VI Tubos (04) strayvector
66. Trinidad Robusto Extra (04) strayvector
67. HDM DC (04) strayvector
68. RA Estupendo AP Regional Release (06) strayvector
69. PL Lonsdale German Regional Release (06) strayvector Swissy
70. Partagas Serie D no.3 LE (06) strayvector Swissy
71. Partagas Short (05) strayvector
72 - RYJ Cedros Deluxe #3 - '96 BlindedByScience
73 - HdM Corona - '96 BlindedByScience
74 - Ramon Allones Small Club Corona - '96 BlindedByScience
75 - VR Familiar - ECA OCT 01 BlindedByScience
76 - ERDM Choix Supreme - SXF FEB 05 BlindedByScience
77 - Cohiba Siglo II - AVC JUL 04 BlindedByScience
78 - Cohiba Siglo VI - FIM NOV 05 BlindedByScience
79 - Montecristo Robusto EL 2000 Swissy
80 - HdM Piramides EL 2003 Swissy
81 - HdM Epicure #2 '94 Swissy
82 - ERDM Choix Supreme '96 Swissy
83 - Vegas Robaina Familiar '98 Swissy
84 - San Cristabal El Principe '00 Swissy
85 - BBF '03 Swissy
86 - CoRo '04 Swissy
87 - Sig VI '04 Swissy