I've read through all this and am now curious. Of those many of you using SE and DE shaving techniques, who has any comparative experience with the newest products as well?
Myself, it's been years since I last used a DE. (I'll be 50 this year, BTW.) I have never used a straight razor or single edge. Currently, I have been using the Gillette Fusion with their same-branded HydraGel. First a hot shower to soften and open up the pores, shave at the sink, final rinse with cold water and pat dry. I finish with Zirh Erase.
I have moderately sensitive neck area, but this combination allows me to shave every day now without any irritation issues. Moreover, it is the closest shave Ive ever had, bar none. I can often skip a day if I feel like it, and only by the end of Day 2 would anyone else notice. Only once have I had a barbershop shave, and this method I'm using is absolutely a
much closer shave. I don't know if I'd be inclined to go through any more ritual that I am now, and this straight razor thing does seem like a lot more work for what may well be nowhere near as close.
That's why I am asking if anyone has really compared the Fusion system (not the older Mach 3) to say definitively that straight razors with good soap and lather really gives that close of a shave. I'm having trouble believing.