personal User said:
Oh yeah, Jonesy I have a request.
Please help me figure out how to get more actual cigar info other than cost/pricing into the remaining part of the pass.
Not as a rule change but a suggested guide for the players.
I really was sincere when I said I think there is far too much focus on costs and not enough on the actual smokes.
I'm not interested in beating a dead horse .. hopefully it is dead .. but flavor is subjective, appearance is subjective, mouthfeel, draw, wrapper preferences, Gary's prick ... all subjective. Two things that are objective are origin and price. MSRP is posted by the manufacturer, so that doesn't change, where as what a cigar sells for is variable. Since price can be measured, and multiple sources can be readily found, an average price can be reached. An average price seems more reasonable than MSRP (typically), so it gives a fairly clear and easily accessible valuation to everyone to trade cigars with. You're hosting the pass,
so you will have to do the research for every trade; it is part of what you signed up for whether you realized it or not. You may not have realized it because even in those passes that say 'You're all
seasoned passers, so your trades are pre-approved', there is a lot of conversation in PMs behind the scenes that you never see posted. People with integrity, aka seasoned passers, will still PM the host when they have a question about a trade and if it works. ... But one of the long standing 'rules of thumb' has always been, participate in several passes before you host one. Then some of those unwritten rules become more clear.
But to your question, contests are a great way. You can have people research research cigars they put, take, whatever ... Reviews: people can post reviews of the cigars they take, that way everyone can learn a little even if he/she wasn't able to take that cigar. ... Stories: people's experiences, favorite memories, funny story's, famous encounters, office encounters with the secretary ... Use your imagination. Why do you like cigars? And extrapolate ...
As Rod stated, we are just trying to help and see that this remains a fun place to hang. It's our home away from home.
Good luck!