If you want the wish, by all means please have it, as I want to share with you (or someone else) the joys of pipe smoking.
Nice post, Jake. OK, then, I'll step up to the plate... my address is in my profile...
I'm a guy who's been smoking cigars for 14 years, so that's the planet I'm from... and I'm a total pipe newbie.
If someone out there with an extensive stash wanted to take a few moments, glance through their collection, and pick out a few things they liked when they started, and send them on, I'd be thrilled.
I suspect given my cigar preferences that I will not be all that interested in aromatics or cased tobacco in general, but hell, I don't know.
In general, I'm trying to keep things somewhat simple to start. In particular, I only have one pipe, and so I don't want to smoke anything too weird in it... and I probably couldn't appreciate anything too exotic at this point, anyway.
I tend to smoke cigars with at least three to five years of age on them, as I don't like too much nicotine, so I'd definitely prefer pipe tobacco without a lot of kick... and I'd be really interested in trying some pipe tobacco with a few years of age on it.
BTW, I'll be happy to grant a wish for someone if they had any cigar related wishes... and will keep an eye on this thread for wishes of that sort...