I have always kept Padrons for a few years, and was very happy with how they smoked. I Have always honestly thought that we have to consider a distinction between preservation, and aging.
Wouldn't it be reasonable to surmise that lower humidity will hasten oil loss, and higher levels retard oil loss? In my own experience, with most smokes this seems to be the case, as I alway try to preserve.
That said, others have already mentioned how much aging the various Padron Lines go through. In that respect, I think that threw me a curve. Up to date, I would have to say about 2 or 3 years max, for the top shelf smokes, have brought me acceptable results. I have only had a few older than that, and they were not very good. Fresh boxes still taste the best to me.
The curve I did just experience a first in that I opened a box of 1926 #6 Maduros that I bought within the past 2 years. These are my favorite cigars, and I've smoked hundreds of them.
The first one I smoked was EXTREMEL:Y floral. I did not enjoy it at all. I smoked another be sure, and sure as shinola, both were the same.
I have kept #6 longer, and never experienced this. Stored at 69% dead nuts humidity.
So, a pile of money, possibly down the tubes. Only choice I have is to let them sit a year or two, and see if they improve.
Not quite sure what to think at this point. Bad batch? Inconsistent results based on crops? These are definitely a differant animal, and I think that in the future, I will try to smoke them within 2 years.