Duck, gawntrail!
The soap boxes are coming out. Piracy is a four letter word here..
I don't like giving ANY money to the RIAA. Unfortunately there are a lot of good bands on their labels, and I listen to a LOT of music. I simply have been buying all of my CDs used for the last 5 years.
I used to join and quit BMG 2 times a year per their rules, and additional times when/if they sent me come back requests. That was a good way to get new CDs for under $4 each after shipping and the one required purchase. They are still making a lot of money that way though, so I stopped.
I go to 2 different Half Priced Books stores weekly and head straight for the $1-$3 clearance CD section. The market is flooded with used CDs and I get very good titles all the time. Last trip I got Pink Floyd 2, Soundtrack to The Crow, Bush's 16 Stone, Edie Brickell's Shooting Rubberbands at the Moon, and Sarah McLachlan's Fumbling Towards Ectasy for $5 + tax. I have had to upgrade my CD storage system twice this year thanks to Half Priced Books. Case Logic Pro-Sleeves are wonderful for reducing the amount of space CDs take up.
-Matt-