Alright, last man standing...
Lets begin with:
Take - (1) 5 Vegas Gold Robusto 2.85(CI 2.75/Stogieboys 2.90/Cigar.com 2.90
Put - Cuban Bullet Robusto 2.95(Famous 2.75/Cigar.com 3.15/bestcigarprices.com 2.95)
Take- (23) Stradivarius de los Maestros Robusto Major (No coffin)
OK, so based on what I could find.
Produced in 07, so right on the verge of adding value at the 5 year mark as a discontinued/one time offering.
No references to how the lack of coffin affects price, it appears that everything was priced with a coffin.
Available at the following fine retailers: Serious 28.80\Pipes and Cigars 25.95\Thompson 32\Discountcigardepot.com 24.20\Bonita smoke shop 28.80\Phoenixcigar.com 28.65\thecigarstore.com 24.26 Avg: 27.52
I don't have anything even close to trade 1:1. But, based on various thread comments I know that some Strad's were discounted by various B&Ms which sold them for $10-15ea. JR Cigars website is still advertising 5rs of the Churchill at $12ea. I have not found production numbers, but the robustos still appear to be fairly available.
With that in mind, I offer the following:
Put- Opus Double Corona (vitola $16)
<waiting for shitstorm>
I likely have some other P/Ts, but all my notes(at work) are based on the original list of cigars. I'll look over the rest of the list and offer some other puts after I have time to look things over this weekend, plus attempt a rework on the Strad if I can narrow the price range.