Onyx Reserve
Overrated but not terrible bad.
La Gloria Cubana Series R
I love La Gloria Cubana's. One of my favorites
Cusano Xclusivos perfecto
Cusano makes great, economically priced cigars. Another one of my favorites.
Nat Sherman
Pretty wimpy. Highly rated mild cigar for those who like 'em.
Trilogy by Alec Bradley (weird triangular cigar)
I didn't like anything about this cigar, especially it's goofy shape.
Oliva "O" natural
Didn't like this cigar. Very uneven cigar. Unimpressive flavor. Kinda tight draw.
Ghurka (some naturals, maduros, and perfecto-shaped)
Most of the Ghurkas are pretty good. I've had some with tight draws, though.
CAO MX2
CAO Maduro
CAO Criollo
I love CAO, especially the maduro. The MX2 is strong and flavorful.
Torano Exodus
Torano Tribute
Torano Signature
Toranos is good, although I think they're slightly overrated, too.