Head to Head

[Peekay]

I need to get on the ball, have had only the Opus in that list, so i guess that's my vote.

 

[cigarsarge]

Gotta be the 1926...To be more specific the 1926 #9.

 

[indyrob]

I voted for the VSG. Great smoke, I'm very fond of the Enchantment and the Illusion second.

 

[fetterjohn]

I made the mistake of voting for the '26. I like the Opus X better...I thought I was voting for the PAM 64. My bad...I guess I should have done some better readin'. :whistling:

-Fetter

<edit...because I'm dumb>

 

[LouieD]

The 26 maduro gets my vote. An absolutely awesome smoke! Followed by the Opus, Anjeo, and VSG. I agree with KB, the couple of EDSs I have had were bad both in burn and taste profile. I couldn't even finish the last one I smoked.

 

[wam79]

I voted for the Shark, but tomorrow I would vote for the 26
they are both great
The 26 is a guarantee great smoke every time
The Anejo has a taste that I really like and the rarity factor makes them a special smoke
The last three would be Opus, VSG and then EDS


Bill

 

[Fyodor]

Edicion De Silvio by Perdomo

[snapback]226278[/snapback]​

Well I sat at work today trying to figure out what an EDS is and after about an hour or two I finally figured it out. Never had one but I've hated every Perdomo I've had to the extent that I would never pay the exorbitant price for this one. Diamond crown maximus should have definitely made it to the list and possibly something from La Flor Dominicana or the Davidoff millenniums in my very humble opinion.

 

[OutlawD]

well i voted for the padron but would have opted for an "all of the above" option
sat here for a good 5 minutes trying to decide

 

[jcpyro]

So far I've only had the VSG so i had to vote for it.

 

[Cheeze]

I need to get on the ball, have had only the Opus in that list, so i guess that's my vote.

[snapback]226324[/snapback]​

Same here!! :blush:

 

[Lemon]

This is a tough poll, but I would go with the Anejo. I've only had one, but it left me the best impression of the cigars I've had so far. Opus X and Padron are, of course, amazing cigars. VSG's are very nice, but not in the same league with the afore mentioned cigars imho. I have not smoked an EDS.

 

[atuck]

Now that I know more about the EDS I see why nobody voted for them. How the **** did they even get on the list? :laugh:

 

[AVB]

The Master's opinion does not match either mine or Moki's. I put it on the list because they belong there IMO.

Now that I know more about the EDS I see why nobody voted for them. How the **** did they even get on the list? :laugh:

[snapback]227670[/snapback]​

 

[gatorsmg]

Good poll...results aren't surprising

Padron 1926 for me :love:

 

[MonkeyK]

Now that I know more about the EDS I see why nobody voted for them. How the **** did they even get on the list? :laugh:

[snapback]227670[/snapback]​

EDS are a great smoke. Not a strong cigar, but very nice with a superb finish. But we are all different: My favorite cigar is the Shark but I can't seem to enjoy Opus X.

 

[sir-smokes-a-lot]

Man, all are quality smokes.

Went for the VSG myself, as I have had the most of them.
A very close 2nd would be the Perdomo edicion de silvios.
And then FFOX and PAM '26 about the same.


tho the real differences are small in-between.
:thumbs:


On a side note, EDS' are very different from some of the other Perdomos.
In reality, Perdomo has a Perdomo2 [IMHO the yellows are better then the reds], the La Tradicion line, Compay, Immenso, Cuban Parejo and others.

So, n earlier statement on this thread could be likened to "Man, I've hated every "Fuente Curly Head"/"Padron Fumas" I've smoked ... would never pay for an "Opus X"/"PAM '26"."

[disclaimer, def. not knockin Fuentes here]

 

[Fyodor]

So, n earlier statement on this thread could be likened to "Man, I've hated every "Fuente Curly Head"/"Padron Fumas" I've smoked ... would never pay for an "Opus X"/"PAM '26"."

[snapback]227786[/snapback]​

Good point. I'm just a bit biased against Perdomo due to past experiences in wasted money. I'm sure these are much better than the other Perdomo's I've had.

 

[Seamus]

Padron 26 for me also. The Opus and the Anejo both a very close second.

 

[Drake]

i voted for the 26. never had a anejo or EDS, though.

 

[The Master]

The EDS in my opinion is a boring one dimensional over priced cigar. They have no business on the same list as 1926, Opus and VSG because of their total lack of flavor and pathetic construction.

I vote for the Opus, I love the 1926 but the price on it is stupid. I can buy my favorite sized Opus( Fuente Fuente) for 9 bucks a stick.