Well, I had this bottle laying around and decided to bring it to my Niece's wedding a few weeks ago for the guys attending that drink good scotch. After the ceremony on the Barnegat Bay, we headed over to the reception hall for the cocktail hour and a half...perfect length!
I grabbed my brother (father of the bride), our oldest brother, and 2 other guys that drink scotch. We cracked that baby open and poured the 5 glasses. We toasted to the happy couple and all took a sip....we all paused for a few seconds and almost simultaneously said, "holy sh*t...this is really good!" It was like a moment frozen in time as the 5 of us talked about how smooth, bright, fruity, and how sweet on the finish this scotch was. It hit each of us the same way at the same time which seemed a bit strange as usually we have varying opinions on scotch when we all drink together. The only difference in opinion was some thought it thin as some thought it thicker, I found it kind of silky.
We talked for a while as we all finished up our first glass and immediately poured another...and then toasted to my brother for paying threw the nose for this extravagant night and how fortunate the rest of us felt getting a free ride on his nickel! We then broke up to go mingle around with family and friends as I put the bottle down on one of the cocktail tables. Periodically we would bump into each other during the next hour or so to comment on how good this scotch was....like a, 'where has this been all our lives' type of reaction as we would pour another glass. Needless to say, we polished off the bottle before we got to dinner, but emptied it just as we started...the 5 of us together, clanging our glasses as we married off another female Roberti.
I would agree that I like this one better than the 18yo in terms of drinkability...nothing too complex to have to pay attention on every sip to disseminate each flavor, but very tasty up front that made you come back for more very frequently. I didn't find it 'hot' in the least and the finish was lasting awhile...but then again, I was sipping this at a rapid pace while trying not to guzzle it!
I'm on the hunt for a few more bottles now....this will be in my regular rotation along side the Highland Park 18, Glenfiddich 15yo Distillery Edition 102 Proof, and the Cragganmore’s 1992 Distiller’s Edition.