If you going for NCs, you definitely want to go with the stronger blends if you want them to age well over several decades. I would suggest looking at Litto Gomez Small Batch cigars. the No. 3 and No. 4 are both readily available right now. They make for a great smoke and are strong enough to age. Of the two, I do think the No. 3 smokes/tastes better to my palate than the No. 4, but YMMV. Best of all they come in boxes of 105 cigars, so you and your wife can both smoke one on your anniversary, and even your kid(s), when they are old enough, can join in...with no fear of a shortage of cigars.