For me, it's either a Cuban cigar or something from the Fuente line. I've been big into Fuentes since I started smoking cigars 20 years ago.
And my opinion is that I still get as much pleasure and enjoyment out of the various Fuentes (858 natties and SG, Double Chateau Fuente SG, DC #2, Hemingway (all sizes - nattie, maduro and SG) and Anjeos) as I did when I started. I haven't noticed any decrease is quality, taste or consistency.
As far as Anejos sitting on the shelf, my guess is that is two-fold. I believe that Fuente is producing more of what used to be HTFs (858 SGs, Hemmingway maddies, Anejos, etc), and the competiton has caught up with them. There are a lot of other cigar makers going the HTF route that are competing for the same consumer $$. And through in some of the boutique brands, and there just isn't the demand for the Anejos and such as there used to be.