I had a tie between the Viaje Private Keep Lemon and the Don Carlos God of Fire. Using the arbitrary deciding factor of availability I'm going with the God of Fire as my COTY.
If you're really bored, here are my 28 top scores. Sticks with the same score are listed alphabetically.
Viaje Private Keep Lemon (Dan) 4/18/24 97
God of Fire (from Todd ) 8/4/24 97
El Septimo Michelangelo (Cigar Chateau, Wich, KS) 8/28/24 96
Big Sky Bighorn 2.0 11/22/24 95
CH Mil Dias Edicion Limitada 2021 (Santino’s) 9/24/24 95
DTT Todas Las Dias 8/20/24 95
Fiero Tego Timeless (Just4Him, Springfield, MO) 8/29/24 95
Foundation Aksum (Gran Cru) 6/16/24 95
Foundation Olmec 8/20/24 95
Foundation The Tabernacle 10/21/24 95
Luciano Foreign Affair 11/14/24 95
Rojas Unfinished Business 6/20/24 95
Tatuaje Cojona 2012 White Ecuador Sumatra 8/31/24 95
(Cigar Chateau, Wich, KS)
CAO Amason Basin (Todd) 9/22/24 94
CH Las Calaveras 2020 (GC) 10/19/24 94
Crowned Heads, La Imperiosa (Todd B) 4/7/24 94
DTT Red Meat Lovers with Ben B 1/16/24 94
Espinosa Murciélago 3/12/24 94
HVC Black Friday 2022 (Dan L. 3 pink) 7/15/24 94
HVC Black Friday 2023 (Dan L. 3 pink) 12/12/24 94+
Illusione Cruzado 6/19/24 94
Illusione Corojo 8/12/24 94
Luciano The Dreamer 9/13/24 94
My Father La Promesa 6/2/24 94
Tatuaje Drac 3/26, 6/12 94
Tatuaje Reserva 10/8/24 94
Tatuaje 20th 4/19/24 94
Viaje Zombie Antidote 7/17/24 94
El Cheapo COTY - La Finca
I would love to be able to smoke those top sticks above and rank them, but I'll leave that for another life.
