But life was not all well with Winfield. At some point in the 1930s, his life took a turn for the worse when a prostitute he visited frequently, named Elizabeth, turned up pregnant and claimed his was the child she carried. For a while he paid her to stay away, afraid of the scandal that such a child could bring to his business. When it was no longer possible to hide the pregnancy, Winfield lured her to Room 109 of his hotel and chained her to a radiator. There she stayed, supplied with food and water, until the child was born. According to some, Elizabeth died in childbirth. Others contend that Winfield solved the problem with more finality by brutally murdering her. Either way, she was found dead. George Winfield then took the baby and threw it into the open mine shaft over which his hotel was built.