So this has been in the works for a while now, somewhat borrowing from another website, but going further! This will be a long ongoing review series to determine if any American cigar producer can catch Don Pepin and his Tatuaje.
The Lineup (big hitters):
Flor De Gonzales Gold
Avalon Cigars Honeyboy Edwards
New Orleans Cigar Factory Tres Series
Tatuaje Reserva
Padilla Miami 8/11
Don Pepin Serie JJ
Puff N Stuff Don Pepin Blue Label
Don Pepin Blue Label
Cabaiguan
El Rey de Los Habanos
Tatuaje Cabinet
Island Smoke Shop El Original
Island Smoke Shop Santiago Cubana
La Gloria Cubana (Miami)
Don Pablo Cuban Round
Las Memorias Cubana
La Tradicion Cubana Anniversario
La Tradicion Cubana
Sabor Cubana
FP H98
Later in the Review (the underdogs):
Lianos Dos Plamas
El Titan de Bronze
Conch Cigars
La Rosa Cubana
To do something unbiased, the order will be in order of strength of the cigar. I hope you guys like this idea and will watch for the thread to show up in the Review section
Now onto the contest! It'll be a long term contest as this review will be going on for a long time.
Guess the order of the top 3 cigars for the review.
If you have any other great American cigars to add to the underdogs, please let me know.
The Lineup (big hitters):

Flor De Gonzales Gold
Avalon Cigars Honeyboy Edwards
New Orleans Cigar Factory Tres Series
Tatuaje Reserva
Padilla Miami 8/11
Don Pepin Serie JJ
Puff N Stuff Don Pepin Blue Label
Don Pepin Blue Label
Cabaiguan
El Rey de Los Habanos
Tatuaje Cabinet
Island Smoke Shop El Original
Island Smoke Shop Santiago Cubana
La Gloria Cubana (Miami)
Don Pablo Cuban Round
Las Memorias Cubana
La Tradicion Cubana Anniversario
La Tradicion Cubana
Sabor Cubana
FP H98
Later in the Review (the underdogs):
Lianos Dos Plamas
El Titan de Bronze
Conch Cigars
La Rosa Cubana
To do something unbiased, the order will be in order of strength of the cigar. I hope you guys like this idea and will watch for the thread to show up in the Review section
Now onto the contest! It'll be a long term contest as this review will be going on for a long time.
Guess the order of the top 3 cigars for the review.
If you have any other great American cigars to add to the underdogs, please let me know.