I'll add my $.02 - I've not had a VSG with anything more than about 6 mos. of age on it (that's how old the box of CGs in my cooler is, anyway), but even the fresh ones I have smoked have all been among the smoothest cigars I've had, right down to the nub every time. IMO, you have to be sure to let the cigar dry out a little bit before smoking it, though, as at 70% the flavors are too muted. Closer to 60%, I think, is probably best. I never smoke VSGs straight from my B&M anymore for that reason, and once they've had a month or more in my humi the flavors open up a lot better. Although I have not smoked all the sizes (or probably even half of them), I agree with Brandon on the large vs. small ring as well; in my experience the smaller cigars really kick it up a notch in the flavor department - the Tres Mystique, Illusion, and Corona Gorda are awesome, and they're the only sizes I even buy anymore.