• Hi Guest - Sign up now for Secret Santa 2024!
    Click here to sign up!
  • Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Punch Petite Coronation ISOM tubo

Lumberg

Opus Lover
Joined
Oct 25, 2003
Messages
3,708
Ok I got this cigar from the Pablamos company.

First off the cigar smelled like dung. Cow dung, horse dung, whatever you want to call it. This was a good thing.

When I put it in my mouth it had a familiar gritty feeling that I usually get from Candelas. I assume it's sugar granules. It tasted good. Earthy.

When I punched it the draw was TIGHT. I punched another overlapping circle. Still tight. I got a paperclip and poked it from both ends. Still tight but now smokeable.

When stepped outside and lit it there was a light floral smell that I couldnt' quite identify.

Once I started smoking it in earnest I was like, "WOW!" This cigar just kept giving and giving. Hard to describe any one particular flavor except I woudl say earthy. Not too strong either flavor wise or nicotine wise.

As I smoked it I just felt sophisticated. Like I was finally experiencing the best that cigars have to offer. It was just SOOOOO good.

You know the harshness you get in the draw when the cigar goes out? Usually just disgusting. Even THIS flavor was good in this cigar. Seriously. This cigar coudl do no bad. I was thinking about emailing Pablamos and saying sell me whatever cigars you have that are from the box this one came from.

Towards the end the draw just got WAAAY too tight though..At times I was not holding the cigar tightly and I was sucking the whole thing into my mouth!

Here is a review from their website:

Very disappointing due to being rolled too tightly. I purchased a box and have found every individual cigar (I've attempted to smoke over half) to be much too tight to be enjoyable. It actually takes over an hour to "smoke" one of these. Having purchased them via the internet from an authorized dealer in Spain, it's rather impractical to attempt to return them. - Submitted by lpa on October 8, 2003


since it was in a tube, and I had opened the tube once yesterday, I don't think you could make the case that it was over humidified. It was just plain rolled too tight.

The burn was moderately even, no serious burn issues but not perfectly straight either.

Flavor--10/10. The single best tasting cigar I have ever smoked. Ever.

Construction-- 3/10 The roller needs to go back to school. Reviewer was right. Took WAAAAY too long to smoke.

I have smoked maybe 8 Cuban cigars in my life. A Lusitania, a Boli PC, am RyJ PC, and an RyJ Churchill among others. I never understood what the hype was all about.

NOW I understand what the hype was all about. I would be sorely tempted to trade my entire cigar collection for a box of these if they drew properly.
 
I was not as impressed as you were. The cigar was good but nowhere near the RyJ Churchill I smoked. In fact I prefer many domestics over this particular stogie. Oh well, that's why they make so many varieties :)

EDIT:
Scratch everything I said, I had a different stogie. So Sorry. Mine was the RyJ #3. I should have read better or at least sober b/f making the post.
 
The roller needs to go back to school
Lumby, those are machine made.

Most Havanas have a tighter draw than your average non-Havana. When I first started smoking Havanas, I found that characteristically tight draw a little un pleasant but the more I smoke Havanas, the more I like that semi-tight draw. I hate smoking cigars that feel like you're smoking straw.

Now once in a while (actually much less than non Havanas) you'll get a plugged one. That unfortunately is just the unluck of the draw.

I never understood what the hype was all about.
When I first started smoking Havanas, I felt the same way, but you have to smoke more than just a couple of dozen to get used to them so to speak. I gravitate towards them because now I prefer Cuban tobacco over anything else, especially when the high end domestics cost two to three times your average Havanas.

I'm glad you liked the taste. We'll make a "dark side" believer out of you yet ;)
 
Lumberg said:
......since it was in a tube, and I had opened the tube once yesterday, I don't think you could make the case that it was over humidified. It was just plain rolled too tight.

I have smoked maybe 8 Cuban cigars in my life.
Being in a tube has nothing to do with being over or under humidified. A tube does not "seal off" the cigar. Your discriptions of uneven burning, the cigar going out, and tightness sounds very much like over humidification IMO.

A correction to Coventrycat86, this cigar was both handrolled and machine-made. Both have been discontinued. Information from Min Ron NEE book says the handmade is 5 inches in lenth and the machine-made is 5 1/8.

I do agree with Catboy ( ;) ) that you need to smoke more than 8 total to have any real experience of what you like or don't like. So many factors come into play (morning, afternoon, evening, drink, food, other cigars, age...etc) that can and will change the taste profile of a cigar that smoking only one of a vitola is not giving the cigar a fair assesment. 5 paks are excellent buys for trying cigars. Of course, IMO! :)
 
Uhhhhhhh, the machine made Petit Coronations are not being discontinued as far as I know and I just opened my MRN book and the 707 (In aluminum tubes, box of 25 are in blue typeset indicating that they are still in production. The double asteriks you see below the "packaging" box only apply to the 207, 10's & 25's and the 707 10's, NOT the 707 25's. This to me means that the 707 25's are still and will continue to remain in production.

I just figured the one Lumby had was a machine made ones because everything else that Pablamos was offering as freebies were all machine mades.

Kenny's right about many other factors determining whether or not you REALLY like or dislike a cigar. There have been times where I light up a cigar I really like (for instance my Olivas or ANY Havana :D ) and if I'm not feeling too well or there's not much food in my stomach or I may have just eaten or drank something, all of a sudden my favorite cigar tastes terrible. I learned a while back that if my first exerience with a certain cigar was bad to NOT automatically write that particular brand off. Wait a few days, and try one again. Also as Kenny mentioned smoking a five-pack of any particular cigar (yeah and NOT all five in the same sitting :D ) is really the best way for you to conclude if you really like something or not.

And yep, the first ever Havana I had a long time ago was a Monte #1. I remember saying to myself "What's the big deal about deese here Habanas?" Then, I smoked another one or two and said "Well, these were better than the first but I still cannot get too excited." THEN, I tried other brands, like VR's, RA's, H. Upmanns', etc. and realized that I just don't particularly care for Montes. I've been spiraling out of control towards the "dark side" ever since :0

Also, I've only had three Anejos in my life and I'll give 'em one more chance but so far, all three have been way below expectations :(
 
Hombres.

I can assure you that the Romeo y Julieta no 3 tubo is hand-made as is the Punch Petit Coronation tubo that we sent. There are reviews of these cigars at http://www.cigars-review.org/. I just checked the boxes that they came from too because I almost fell over when I thought they might be machine-made. The bottom of the boxes has Totalmente a mano stamped onto it. When a cigar is machine-made this is missing from the bottom of the box. I am no expert by a long way and am willing to be corrected if I am wrong but.....

Anyway, keep an eye on the other board for the next posting. We are going to be giving away a Cohiba Piramide Edicion Limitada 2001 to whoever wins our fiendishly difficult quiz. Believe me this cigar is a serious work of art and most definitely hand-made. I realise that you guys have a genuine love of and enthusism for cigars and I am very interested to see how you will rate both this and any other prizes that we give away in the future. I think you are going to love them. The Punch tubo we gave away is $3 more or less, the Cohiba LE 2001 $30. Vamos a ver as we say in España.

Un saludo

pablo
 
coventrycat86 said:
This to me means that the 707 25's are still and will continue to remain in production.
I stand corrected. Thanks Catman! I should have put my reading glasses on. :) The original jist was that there was a hand made... of course I can't seem to stop at my original jist's. ??? LOL! I also goofed on the sizes as I was looking at the Coronation instead of the Petit Coronation. Both the handmade and the machine rolled of the "petit" coronation is 4 5/8.

Is there a date and factory code on the Petit Coronation that was smoked? Just curious......
 
I can assure you that the Romeo y Julieta no 3 tubo is hand-made as is the Punch Petit Coronation tubo that we sent.

Oooooops, sorry pablamos, I should have realized that both of those are hand made as well as machine made.

Hey ANY cuban tobacco is #1 in my book and I actually prefer the machine made RyJ #3 tubos and the Punch PC tubos over their hand-rolled counterparts anyway!!

LOL @ Kenny, I was just lucky that my reading glasses were in arm's reach, MAN that print in the MRN book sure is small :p
Anyway, keep an eye on the other board for the next posting. We are going to be giving away a Cohiba Piramide Edicion Limitada 2001 to whoever wins our fiendishly difficult quiz.

Oh oh, pablamos is going to try to make me use what's left of my brain ???
I'm just going to throw in the towel now, I never did very well on tests in school :p
 
Atencion hombres! Go get yourself a free Cohiba Piramides Ltd Edition 2001 cigar. Pablos quiz is up and running, the clock is ticking and may the best man win. See posting under "hot cigar deals"
 
Top