• Hi Guest - Sign up now for Secret Santa 2024!
    Click here to sign up!
  • Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Padron Melli Maddy Review

PuroBrat

I am not here :^)
Joined
Apr 2, 2002
Messages
4,227
I am not sure what happened to this cigar prior to it getting to moki, and again prior to it getting to me. This WAS I am sure a very nice cigar at someoint(drawing from experience with Padron's quality) but this one was abused, no doubt about it.

At first glance it looked good, with a slight moddled cap but other than that not bad at all. Upon closer inspection while preparing to smoke it, I notice several cracks in the wrapper, and the oily sheen that is a norm with Padron sticks, was AWOL on this one. I tasted the cap prior to cutting it and found none of the tobac taste I expected.It was dry and tasteless. I clipped it with my Xi and it cracked badly. (this cigar was in my humi with my other perfectly humidified smokes mind you) There were two large hard stems visible at the head under the cap, but as they did not effect the draw, I left them alone.

I tested the draw (prelight) and it was like sucking on a straw. It was way to easy and had no flavor. I lit the foot and as soon as it lit, there was audible cracking :0 :angry: . The flavor of this cigar was harsh, bitter and not at all up to par.

I smoked it down to my fingers, there is really nothing to write about until it hit the last 4th of the cigar, then I got some leather, earth and spice. Still was not even up to the standard of the Padron Thousand line, but at least it was flavor.

My feeling on this smoke is that it was not taken care of properly. At some point PMM serial # 098230 was a victom of Criminal Neglect. There is little doubt in my mind that this cigar has seen DRY times :( Much a pitty seeing as how I am equally sure this should have been a great smoke.


Oh yeah: Andrew my brother, thank you much for the Opportunity to try these, sometime I will do it again, with one that still has some oil in it.
 
I DIDNT DO ANYTHING! ITS NOT MY FAULT! THE ONE-ARM MAN DID IT!

:sign: :sign: :sign:

Prior to me handing them to you, they were sitting in my humidor. I didn't really inspect them carefully upon their arrival to me. I just put the pass contents sans the PMMs into the cooler and the PMMs into the humidor. The one I smoked was in good condition. Perhaps not as oily as the other Padron Maduros, but still solid, no less. I will check my other PMM to see how it's holding up...

Sorry to hear about the dud PMM, PB. :(
 
I have a feeling that the damage to this one was well before you got it Phishy, I am sure they have been well caredfor since Moki got them as well, but I get the feeling fromit that it was allowed to dry out sometime prior tothat. I can't believe only ONE in a Humi of 100 would suffer from this though.
 
Aside from the dry wrapper, etc., I was never really impressed with the millennium PAMs. Especially when paired against the regular Anniversario line. From the release date, they were just so-so smokes. So, you probably weren't missing much from one that was in good shape.
 
I was able to try one of these thanks to Moki and I too was disappointed. Mine was not dried out but it had too easy of a draw for me and did not have as nice a taste as a '64 or a '26. I prefer the '26's over th 64's anyway but these Milleniums don't match up to either of those.

Thank you though Moki for making these available to us to try :thumbs:
 
Top