• Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

List of Top 5 Cigars

I feel like there's so many I haven't tried yet, it's hard to pick five "best" from each catagory. But....If I had to choose today based on what I've smoked "so far"...:

ISOM:
1 - RASS (best ISOM I've smoked to date)
2 - Partagas Short (so much flavor in such a small vitola)
3 - Montecristo #1 and / or #2
4 - ERDM "Choix Supreme"
5 - Toss up: Hoyo de Monterrey Le Hoyo du Depute / San Cristobal de la H. El Principe (just got these both but I really like the smaller vitolas for a weeknight smoke, and the first one of each was....fantastic... :thumbs: )

NC:
1 - Fuente Anejo (any, esp. #48's.... :love: Probably the best cigar I've ever smoked, period. )
2 - Padron 64 Anniversary Maduro's (any, esp. the Torpedo)
3 - OpusX (any though the Super Belicoso and the Robusto were both very nice....)
4 - Padron "K Series" (2000,3000,etc.) in maduro. Still, my "go to" smoke. I don't think you can beat 'em for the $$$
5 - LaLuna LLNF "Colada" - little 4X40 powerhouse. Another "small" cigar that really has incredible flavor in a 20-30 min smoke.

...and lots of other that somehow didn't make the list.... :p

Regards - B.B.S.
 
In my limited experience:

NC

Ashton VSG (Enchantment, especially)
Opus X
Punch Rare Corojo Rothchild (aged only)
any Padron
BTL

C

CoRo
VR Famosos
Party Short
HU Mag 46
Trinidad Coloniales


There's so many really good smokes and five is such a hard amount to narrow down. But just sitting and thinking about it certainly brings back some really fond memories of good times and delicious cigars. :D
 
ISOM:
H.Upmann Mag46
Bolivar PC
Bolivar BBF
PLPC
PSD4

Non:
Fuente Chateau Sungrown
Fuente Cuban Beli
 
ISOM:

1) Vegas Robaina Famoso
2) Cohiba Siglo II
3) Montecristo #2
4) Hoyo de Monterey Hoyo Du Gourmet (excuse my spelling)
5) El Rey Del Mundo Choix Supreme



Non ISOM:
1) Partagas 150
2) La Aurora 100 Anos
3) Camacho Negro
4) Avo 22
5) Avo Maduro #9


Darren
 
Non - ISOM

WOAM (In fact, the Classic Maduro ties it) :love: :love:
Opus X "Fuente Fuente"
PAM 64
DCM Robusto
Opus X "DC"

ISOM

PSD#4 :love:
Punch Punch
Trinidad Fundadore (When it draws well)
Cohiba Siglo VI
Mag46
 
Here are my top 5 in each category:
(and yes this board has turned me into a Fuente whore... :laugh: )

isom
1) Por Larranaga PC
2) RASS
3) Vegas Robaina Famosos
4) Hoyo de Monterrey Le Hoyo du Dieux
5) Juan Lopez PC

non
1) Arturo Fuente Hemingway Best Seller
2) P A M 1964 Exclusivo
3) Arturo Fuente WOAM
4) Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
5) Ashton VSG Tres Mystique
 
ISOM
Cohiba Siglo VI
Partagas Presidente
RASS
VR Famoso
Romeo Celestial Fino

N/C
Padron '26
Padron '64
*Rocky Patel "Big Daddy" Maduro*
Stanford Cameroon
Fuente Sig. Maduro


*experimental RP blend I taste tested during my trip to Honduras*
(closest thing to a Padron 64 I've ever tasted)
 
Havanas:

Esplendidos
Siglo V
Lanceros
Cohiba Robustos
Trinidad Robustos Extras

NC:

Padron '26 #9M
VSG Tres Mystique
Opus X Super Beli
Fuente Cuban Beli
JR Ult Cab #10
 
ISOM;

Bolivar Corona Gigante
MC EL 2003
Partagas series D
Hupman Mag 46
Sancho Panza any size

NON C;

RP The Edge Maduro Torpedo
RP Vintage 1990 any size but prefer Torpedo
Padron 1926 or 64' maduro Pyramid(any size will do)
Ashton VSG Sorcerer (any size will do)
JdN Antono Toro

Alternate for me is Oliva O maduro torpedo:)
 
NC
1. PAM 64 and 1926 any size
2. LFD Double Ligero Chisel
3. Gurkha Ledgend
4. Anejo
5. Opus

Cuban
1. Bolivar PC
2. PSP 2
3. Party shorts
4. Bolivar Belisco
5. Cohiba Robusto
 
Limiting it to 5 only is pretty tough but here are my choices.

Non Cuban:

PAM Monarca

Opus X Fuente Fuente

Diamond Crown 6

Davidoff Millenium Lonsdale

Don Carlos # 3

Cuban:

Cohiba Lancero

Partagas Seleccion Privada 1

Partagas Serie Du Connoisseur 1

Upmann Monarch

Trinidad Fundadores
 
ISOM
Never smoked any, but will update as I have the opportunity to

N/C
#1 Anejo #46
#2 Sancho Panza Extra Fuerte
#3 Rocky Patel Vintage 1990
#4 H. Upmann Vintage Cameroon
#5 Punch Rare Corojo Rothschild
 
No isom experience, only domestics on my list.

1. PAM 26, any size
2. AF Hemmingway Signature Maduro
3. PAM 64, any size
4. AF Hemmingway Short Story
5. Punch Rare Corojo Rothschild

So much I haven't tried so I'm sure my list will change many time in the future.
 
SabresFan said:
No isom experience, only domestics on my list.

1. PAM 26, any size
2. AF Hemmingway Signature Maduro
3. PAM 64, any size
4. AF Hemmingway Short Story
5. Punch Rare Corojo Rothschild

So much I haven't tried so I'm sure my list will change many time in the future.
[snapback]289387[/snapback]​
Click to expand...

actually, i dont think any of those are domestics either :p .
 
Well, right now, I'd have to go with the following:

Habanos
Partagas Serie du Conn. No. 1
Partagas Lonsdale
Bolivar Corona Extra
Ramon Allones 898 Varnished
Trinidad Fundadores

Non-Cubans
Padron 1964 Exclusivo Maduro
Padron 1926 No. 2 Natural
Opus X No. 4
Avo LE5
Ashton VSG Belicoso No. 1

This of course changes on a fairly regular basis depending on my mood, alignment of the stars, etc.
 
ISOM
Cohiba Siglo IV
Cohiba Lancero
Partagas Aristocrat
RASS
PSD #4

Domestic
Opus X-Fuente Fuente
DCM Toro & robusto
PAM 64 Torpedo
Bolivar (newest blend) Robusto Tubo
Ashton VSG (all sizes)
 
Greetings! This is my List of Top 5 Cigars: 1) Padron Serie 1926, No. 1 (Maduro), Nicaragua, Double Corona. 2) Arturo Fuente Anejo, Reserva Shark No. 77, Dominican Republic, Perfecto. 3) Joya de Nicaragua, Classic, Nicaragua, Churchill. 4) Punch Grand Cru, No. II (Maduro), Honduras, Torpedo. 5) El Rey del Mundo, Robusto Larga, Honduras, Toro. These are not my everyday cigars, though. My favorite everyday cigar is the El Rey del Mundo (Honduras) Oscuro Robusto. Enjoy your favorite cigars! Regards, knightlaird
 
my top five domestic

1. Opus
2. Padron '64
3. Partagas limited reserve 10yr vintage
4. Don Carlos
5. Cuesta Ray CFS
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top