• Hi Guest - Sign up now for Secret Santa 2024!
    Click here to sign up!
  • Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

JR Ultimate Oscuro and HdM Excalibur

Lumberg

Opus Lover
Joined
Oct 25, 2003
Messages
3,708
I'm not going to do a long review on these. I smoked em while doing stuff and thoroughly enjoyed both.

The Oscuro was very surprisingly good. I was going to a BBQ and I brought soem cigars thinking it was goign to be an outdoor affair. It was mostly indoors with the chef cookign outside. I grabbed the stick to go "supervise the cook" and figured this was OK if the food was ready soon and I couldn't smoke it all.

Man was I wrong! This cigar was soooo good. Now I am not the world's foremost expert on cigars but IMO all the hype is absolutely true. It stacks up very well against the Opus Xs and Hemingway maddies of the world. If not for the price this would be a premium cigar without a doubt.

I smoked the Excalibur while puttering in my garage. It was quite good also with the flavor and strength staying quite steady throughout. At times there was uneven burning but it self corrected both times. Pretty much what I expected--a decent workhorse cigar.
 
Lumberg said:
Man was I wrong! This cigar was soooo good. Now I am not the world's foremost expert on cigars but IMO all the hype is absolutely true. It stacks up very well against the Opus Xs and Hemingway maddies of the world. If not for the price this would be a premium cigar without a doubt.
Interesting. I've heard very mixed things about the JR Ultimates... from incredibly good to dog rocket. I wonder what's up? Seems like more than individual taste...
 
I have smoked several JR Ultimates and never had a bad one. Good bang for the buck.
 
Just ordered 2 more boxes. :thumbs: I'v smoked Principals in X, Coronas in X, #1 Beli in X, and the Cabinet #10 in SG. I always have at least one box of each on hand. They aren't the best cigars in the world but are far from dog rockets. I do believe they are the best cigar for the price. ;)
 
moki said:
Interesting. I've heard very mixed things about the JR Ultimates... from incredibly good to dog rocket. I wonder what's up? Seems like more than individual taste...
I think you may be confusing the Ults with the Alts. Alts have a pretty bad rep whereas I've seen very few disparaging remarks regarding the Ults. As for myself I've never had an Alt but I am hooked on the Ult Cabs (SG). I especially love the 50's and 70's.
 
lucasbuck said:
I think you may be confusing the Ults with the Alts. Alts have a pretty bad rep whereas I've seen very few disparaging remarks regarding the Ults. As for myself I've never had an Alt but I am hooked on the Ult Cabs (SG). I especially love the 50's and 70's.
I've tried quite a few of the different "Alts". The only ones that I liked are the La Gloria Cubana Cuban Alternative and the Punch Pita Alternative.

Those are the only two I'd smoke again.

Best,
Gus
 
Top