• Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Johnny-O! XMBF

tomthirtysix

Wishing I was as cool as Phil
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
7,073
A couple times a year I take a day off and meet up with my old college roommate for a day of cigar smoking. We manage to sprinkle a few drinks and some food in, as well. And with Winter fast approaching, we figured we'd get together before snow starts falling. I brought along a couple Johnny-O! XBMFs for us to smoke at some point during the day, and once my friend saw them, he couldn't wait and wanted that to be the first smoke.
(Apologies in advance for the pictures, I took them on my phone. I wasn't carrying a camera around all day.)

IMG00233.jpg


This 8x57 monster is modeled after the Fuente Opus X BBMF. It had a beautiful, dark wrapper, great construction, and was just begging to be lit. We cut the shag heads off, and were off. Prelight draw on mine was pretty tight, but I expected it, since it has the nipple foot. My friend said his was fairly open, considering the vitola. Both cigars started off crooked, but again, something we expected considering the design. About halfway up the bulb foot, I decided I had to open mine up some more, so I clipped a little more from the head. Now, I was in business. By the time both cigars got over the bulb, the burn straightened out. This cigar was strong, with a lot of leather up front.

IMG00234.jpg


Around the midpoint, the draw started to tighten up again. I tapped out the ash, cut another sliver off the top, and the draw was great again. It was around this same time my friend recut his, too. Just a little past halfway, I got a quick hint of white pepper. And as fast as it came on, it was gone.

The last 3" of the cigar got real strong. I was really loving this smoke. The only problem was, this behemoth, plus a couple Belhaven Scottish Ales (which was a perfect pairing, by the way), plus hunger setting in, and I was having visions of being new to cigars and powering my way through LFD DLs.

IMG00235.jpg


Unfortunately, I had to tap out shortly after this, and go searching for some food. My friend said this was the best Johnny-O! he's ever smoked, and I would probably have to agree. Next time I get some of these I will be sure to load up on food first so I can enjoy the cigar longer. Total smoking time was a little over 2 hours.
 
Tom - thanks for a great review. I have a few of these in the cabinet waiting.....

I'm curious - when you had your draw problems and found a slight cut made the draw OK, did you notice any tar build up on the end of the cigar....??
 
I have one sleeping. Thanks for the review Tommy! :thumbs: I'll have to look forward to the leather notes you picked up! :) Oh yeah regarding Tom's question, what say you Tommy?


Best,

Joe
 
I wish Johnny sold these in a fiver, like to try one and rest the other. On my to do list.
 
I re-cut twice. The first time was very early on, and that was because my initial cut was too high. When I made that cut, I wanted to err on the side of caution, because I've never had a cigar like this. That one wasn't because of tar, that was because the cut wasn't low enough.

My second re-cut, there was the very beginning of a small tar build up. I never noticed it taste-wise, but that was definitely the cause. Just another little sliver off the top cleared the problem away. And I never noticed any other tar the rest of the way through the smoke.

One other note - Joe and Tom, you both said you had some resting. These were fresh. I smoked them just over a week after I got them. I know John's smokes usually arrive somewhat moist because of how fresh they are, so I thought I might run into a problem because of the tight time constraints. I kept them in a dry box as soon as I got them, it held around 50 - 55% the whole time.

Edit to add: Tom - I just read your Anejo thread. I know your pain there, but the tiny bit of tar I saw here was nowhere near the pain that Anejos bring. Like I said, when I did see a little tar, it was just starting to build up around the outside of the cut, and that one correction did the trick.
 
Very nice looking smoke, how long did it take to get through? That lounge looks pretty nice, well, nicer than what I have here in Des Moines. I know that may be hard to believe, but it's true. Was the Belhaven on tap? I love it on tap but it really loses something for me when bottles or in the can. Thanks for the review Tom, looks like a day well spent.
 
That a big cigar,looks really good.
Thanks for the review,I might get some in the future.
 
May I ask as to how long you had this Johnny-O resting for? I know that resting time for Johnny-Os have been discussed numerous times, but I am curious as to how long this particular stick was resting considering you seemed to enjoy it so much. Thanks
 
I have never been able to figure out the perfect time. I have had horrible Johnnys and awesome Johnnys. I would just recommend sitting on thing in an open area for 1+ years. They need to breathe!
 
I wish Johnny sold these in a fiver, like to try one and rest the other. On my to do list.

Dollars to doughnuts John would find a way to accommodate you, Ed.

Steve
 
May I ask as to how long you had this Johnny-O resting for? I know that resting time for Johnny-Os have been discussed numerous times, but I am curious as to how long this particular stick was resting considering you seemed to enjoy it so much. Thanks

I had it for a little more than a week.
 
Great review. Tom. I still haven't smoked the one I have, though I did look at it longingly the other day. I'm trying my hardest to let it sit, but after reading this review, I'm not too sure if I'll be able to hold out much longer. :(
 
Yeah, it is a beautiful place. Unfortunately, it's about a 2 hour drive. I get there a couple times a year to meet a friend there, but we do make the most of the day while we're there.
 
I have one sleeping. Thanks for the review Tommy! :thumbs: I'll have to look forward to the leather notes you picked up! :) Oh yeah regarding Tom's question, what say you Tommy?


Best,

Joe
Me too! Who hooked you up? ???
 
Top