Is there such a thing as a "5" ?

[PuffTheMagicDragon]

I don't know if I've ever smoked a true 5-rated stick. The closest thing to that was a Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour.

Honorable mention goes to recent La Bomba Warhead X and Montecristo Espada.... and a few CC's.

Do I need to readjust my scale ?

What your "5" ?

 

[bfreebern]

I don't know if I've ever smoked a true 5-rated stick. The closest thing to that was a Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour.

Honorable mention goes to recent La Bomba Warhead X and Montecristo Espada.... and a few CC's.

Do I need to readjust my scale ?

What your "5" ?

5 stars?

I've had an AVO22, Cohiba Piramides EL 2001, a 2004 Cohiba Esplendido (from David Sanchez on Fathers Day) and a Padron Millenium. Those 4 stick at the top of my head. The 1998 Trinidad Fundadores are up there too.

 

[BlindedByScience]

I've had Upmann 'Sir Winston' sticks I thought were pretty wonderful. There were others, but this is the first one that comes to mind.

 

[MX]

Grape White Owl or maybe a Moon trance?

 

[CigarStone]

I dated a couple of fives?

Of course that's on a scale of 1-10

 

[lherzolite]

All my fives are the first time smoking them. Ones that come to mind are Trinidad Robusto T, Opus X, AF Anejo, Tat The Frank.

 

[MX]

I dated a couple of fives?

Of course that's on a scale of 1-10

I married a 5
Of course that is on a scale of 1-3

 

[lucasbuck]

Far too many to count. Granted they are rare. I might smoke just a handful or so per year I would rate the highest but it happens regularly. Last couple that come to mind were an ‘02 Punch Ninfas & an ‘01 LGC MdO #1. Oh and a Cohiba Ambar and that was only about a year old.

 

[wrussell46]

All my 5’s are Davidoff…couple of Cubanos in that mix though for sure. I would have to reference the Cigar Journal to be more accurate!