• Hi Guest - Sign up now for Secret Santa 2024!
    Click here to sign up!
  • Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Hemingway Short Story

Ginseng

Banned
Joined
Oct 2, 2005
Messages
8,803
Last night's study smoke was the Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story. Since it was late and I had an 18 page paper to proof read and edit, the only accompaniment was a strong cup of freshly-brewed coffee.

The AFSS is a cute cigar. At only 4" x 48 rg, this little figurado is perfect when you don't have a lot of time but still want a high quality, big cigar "punch." The wrapper is African Cameroon and the internals are Dominican. You can read read about the origins of the Hemingway line in Carlito Fuente's (very own words). This cigar was also reviewed most recently by CP'ers natejustice and sabresfan.

This is the second cigar in my recent and ongoing AF tour. As I remarked in another review, it's been a while since I smoked much from Fuente and I wanted to give it a shot again with a refreshed palate.

Prelight and Initial Stage
This is a solid little stick. The wrapper is a ruddy colorado-maduro with moderate veining and a tough, slightly rough feel to it. External construction was quite good with a nicely formed, domed head and a neat nipple at the foot end. The scent strikes me as "old" tobacco, slightly peppery with a touch of dry wood. This suggests tobacco that has been sufficiently fermented and aged.

After I cut the cap off with my knife, I saw an indicator of potential draw problems. When you're looking down the freshly cut bunch and it looks like a solid disc of tobacco, that usually means a tight or impossible draw. And so, after moistening the region near the head again, I cut another 1/16" off to see if I could locate some channels. Not much luck. A quick draw test revealed that though quite tight, the stick was not plugged. In these cases, I smoke them with the hope that the heat will soften the bunch allowing me to roll the barrel a bit and open the stick up. It seems that even Fuente is not immune to the occasional tight pack but then this is a more likely occurrence with figurados rather than straight-sided parejos.

Light-up went well except for something that I sometimes encounter only with figurados, especially short ones. I find that sometimes I misjudge the point of contact between the tip of the flame and the point of the foot. In this case, I shot too low and ended up lighting the foot quite unevenly on one side. This did not seem to cause a persistent problem as the cigar was able to straighten itself out when the rest of the burn line caught up to the inadvertent torching. I'd caution that the following account is based on a cigar with a pretty tight draw. In my experience, this skews the impression but I cannot say with confidence in what ways other than muting flavors and sometimes adding a certain sourness/bitterness to the impression.

Initial impressions were of a medium-light bodied smoke. There was no discernible pepperiness underlying the predominant woodiness. Snatches of nuts (why am I always tasting cashews?) and dry earth snuck in. A good, dark tobacco flavor was present. Not rich, not creamy but reasonably satisfying nonetheless. The draw continued to be firm but the burn was organically straight with a razor thin burn line. Ash was a very stiff medium gray.

Finish and Final Impressions
I can't say the cigar developed very much. The flavors stayed true to tobacco/dry wood/nuts all the way without any harshness but also without much verve. I also found the smoke to be a little drying on the palate. As I smoked it further down, I got the same feeling that I always seem to get when I smoke Fuente products...nice, but no fireworks. At about the last 3/4" I was able to loosen up the bunch and get a freer draw. The cigar did open up, releasing more earthy and nutty flavors and the smoke actually had a better, more full mouth feel as the nub drew near.

In summation:
Although I don't feel I got the most out of this little cigar due to a tight draw, I think it performed pretty close to expected. If you like the Hemingway profile, you'd probably enjoy this cigar more. For my money, I found the LaGloria Cubana Reserva Figurado Felicias a much more satisfying, complex and flavorsome cigar. The unfortunate thing is that the LGC RF series is not available year-round.

(IMG:http://webzoom.freewebs.com/photonjazz/AFSS01.jpg)
(IMG:http://webzoom.freewebs.com/photonjazz/AFSS02.jpg)

Wilkey
 
I love how you take pictures when you review. Great cigar. Lots of fun to try and smoke without ashing it!
 
By far - one of my all time favorites and consistently a great smoke for me. Been looking for these in maduro - now would be the time if at all. Thank for a great review Wilkey.

Lkyman - Scott
 
Awesome review Wilkey! You noticed some of the same aspects as I did in this stick. Thanks for the great review! :)
 
Wilkey thanks for the review. How ironic that you would use weight lifting gloves to smoke such a small cigar :D Smart move so that you can get your fingers on the nub though.
 
Great review of a fantastic little cigar. :thumbs: Thanks...keep'em up.
 
I've smoked a bunch of these and they do nothing for me. I mentioned this at a herf and the next thing I know I had two in my hand. One new and one aged. I don't know how old but I can tell you that the aged one was great. Then I smoked that new one and it was the same as always. Nothing to write home about. I don't remember who handed the aged one to me, but thanks, if you're reading this. It had great flavor. Now I have a few that will spend time in the cooler-dor.
 
Anthony,
Those are actually polar fleece gloves I cut the fingertips off of so I could smoke in my cold, cold garage. ;) Right on about the nub though :thumbs:

Shibumi,
Age might well be a factor I haven't explored in this line. It's no stretch to think that these high-quality cigars would benefit form some aging. Alas, packed as my humi is with Padrons, there's just no more room to put anything else up, for now.

Jeffb,
Yup, shooting for the "total ash" is great little side light with small, well-made smokes like these. :D

Wilkey
 
Shibumi said:
I've smoked a bunch of these and they do nothing for me. I mentioned this at a herf and the next thing I know I had two in my hand. One new and one aged. I don't know how old but I can tell you that the aged one was great. Then I smoked that new one and it was the same as always. Nothing to write home about. I don't remember who handed the aged one to me, but thanks, if you're reading this. It had great flavor. Now I have a few that will spend time in the cooler-dor.
[snapback]259591[/snapback]​
Any idea on how old the "aged" one was?
 
Ginseng said:
Shibumi,
Age might well be a factor I haven't explored in this line. It's no stretch to think that these high-quality cigars would benefit form some aging. Alas, packed as my humi is with Padrons, there's just no more room to put anything else up, for now.
Wilkey
[snapback]259613[/snapback]​

Idea!! Send me the padrons. I'll replace them with short stories and you'll have plenty of room left. Deal? :laugh:


junkman_56 said:
Any idea on how old the "aged" one was?
[snapback]259617[/snapback]​

I have no clue. I want to say a year, but I had a few beers and can't remember who even gave it to me. :blush:
 
WHile I have no idea how old the aged ones in question were, I have some from a few age groups, from brand spanking new back to about 2001. Anything more than a year makes a good cigar great. More than 2 years, and they are some of my most precious smokes.
Edit to add: I bought the ones with more than 2 years age on them already slightly aged, the oldest that I bought fresh are about a year old.
 
Shibumi said:
Ginseng said:
Shibumi,
Age might well be a factor I haven't explored in this line. It's no stretch to think that these high-quality cigars would benefit form some aging. Alas, packed as my humi is with Padrons, there's just no more room to put anything else up, for now.
Wilkey
[snapback]259613[/snapback]​

Idea!! Send me the padrons. I'll replace them with short stories and you'll have plenty of room left. Deal? :laugh:


junkman_56 said:
Any idea on how old the "aged" one was?
[snapback]259617[/snapback]​

I have no clue. I want to say a year, but I had a few beers and can't remember who even gave it to me. :blush:
[snapback]259621[/snapback]​

Well I gave you the non-aged one!
Maybe that'll help you figure out who the gifter was!
-Rob
 
By far - one of my all time favorites and consistently a great smoke for me. Been looking for these in maduro - now would be the time if at all.

I too would love to get my hands on a maduro short story, very hard to find though.

Ginseng excellent review!!! The pictures are great, I've had a few SS's now and can't get the ash down that far. Nice job!!!
 
rob300c said:
Shibumi said:
Ginseng said:
Shibumi,
Age might well be a factor I haven't explored in this line. It's no stretch to think that these high-quality cigars would benefit form some aging. Alas, packed as my humi is with Padrons, there's just no more room to put anything else up, for now.
Wilkey
[snapback]259613[/snapback]​

Idea!! Send me the padrons. I'll replace them with short stories and you'll have plenty of room left. Deal? :laugh:


junkman_56 said:
Any idea on how old the "aged" one was?
[snapback]259617[/snapback]​

I have no clue. I want to say a year, but I had a few beers and can't remember who even gave it to me. :blush:
[snapback]259621[/snapback]​

Well I gave you the non-aged one!
Maybe that'll help you figure out who the gifter was!
-Rob
[snapback]259639[/snapback]​

Hey Rob, that helps a little. :laugh: The aged one was handed to me right before you put one in my hand, I think I even mentioned it to you at the time. Was it hudsonvalley? Could be. Either way thanks to both. :D
 
Another nice review. I have a box of these from 2001 and they are fantastic! I still like fresh ones too, but not as much as the '01s.
 
Excellent review! This is one of my favorite cigars, I truly love the Cameroon wrapper cigars. Although I've had plenty of these and they are generally very consistent, I too have had a few that were tight.
 
I burned through a box of SS and then definitely got a lot better with over a year of age. I recently tried a fresh best seller and I was very disappointed. I try to make it a habit of letting my cigars rest before I try them now.
 
Top