Guide to rating your cigars

[Rod]

How to Arrive at a Number

Cigar rating system developed by CIGAR AFICIONADO™
(This text is from The Cigar Lover's Diary)

There are four components used in the system developed by CIGAR AFICIONADO™ for assigning a rating number to a cigar:

APPEARANCE AND CONSTRUCTION
(15 of the possible 100 points)

Visually, a premium cigar should have a smooth, flawless wrapper and be consistent in color and shape. When held, it should feel firm and give off a slightly oily moistness. Points are deducted if the wrapper has areas of large veins or if the cigar feels dry or firmer in some parts than others.

FLAVOR
(25 of the possible 100 points)

Although each premium cigar has a distinctive taste, all premium cigars should taste smooth and rich. If a cigar leaves a bitter or harsh taste on your lips, tongue or mouth, points are deducted.

SMOKING CHARACTERISTICS
(25 of the possible 100 points)

A perfectly made and stored premium cigar should light and burn easily and evenly. The draw should be comfortable and the same throughout the cigar. The smoke should be cool in your mouth. Points are deducted if the cigar burns too quickly, if it burns faster on one side, and if you have to pull hard to get a mouthful of smoke or if that smoke is unpleasantly hot.

OVERALL IMPRESSION
(35 of the possible 100 points)

This is the most heavily weighted category because it is the most important.

 

[AVB]

If flavor isn't the most important item then something is wrong with the rating system IMO. It could look like a Backwoods as long as it tasted good and burned half decent. Maybe I'm just in tune with the finer aspects. ???

 

[cigardawg]

If flavor isn't the most important item then something is wrong with the rating system IMO. It could look like a Backwoods as long as it tasted good and burned half decent. Maybe I'm just in tune with the finer aspects. ???

[snapback]189189[/snapback]​

I agree to a point, though nothing will cause me to throw a cigar in the fire-pit faster than a plugged draw. Just can't stand that. :angry2: Anyway, overall impression seems to be one of those intangibles like, "How much did they spend on advertising in my magazine this month?" and "How many free samples did I get when I interviewed him last month?" Just doesn't fit into my rating system.

Appearance is the least important, agreed. Construction (burn) and flavor are close runners, but I have to agree with AVB, flavor is a bit more important.

Just my 0.02.

 

[TonyDogs]

How to Arrive at a Number

Cigar rating system developed by CIGAR AFICIONADO™
(This text is from The Cigar Lover's Diary)

There are four components used in the system developed by CIGAR AFICIONADO™ for assigning a rating number to a cigar:

APPEARANCE AND CONSTRUCTION
(15 of the possible 100 points)

Visually, a premium cigar should have a smooth, flawless wrapper and be consistent in color and shape. When held, it should feel firm and give off a slightly oily moistness. Points are deducted if the wrapper has areas of large veins or if the cigar feels dry or firmer in some parts than others.

FLAVOR
(25 of the possible 100 points)

Although each premium cigar has a distinctive taste, all premium cigars should taste smooth and rich. If a cigar leaves a bitter or harsh taste on your lips, tongue or mouth, points are deducted.

SMOKING CHARACTERISTICS
(25 of the possible 100 points)

A perfectly made and stored premium cigar should light and burn easily and evenly. The draw should be comfortable and the same throughout the cigar. The smoke should be cool in your mouth. Points are deducted if the cigar burns too quickly, if it burns faster on one side, and if you have to pull hard to get a mouthful of smoke or if that smoke is unpleasantly hot.

OVERALL IMPRESSION
(35 of the possible 100 points)

This is the most heavily weighted category because it is the most important.

[snapback]189179[/snapback]​

I think this a good way to rate cigars.
I would assume the overall impression is the key.