• Hi Guest - Sign up now for Secret Santa 2024!
    Click here to sign up!
  • Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

God of Fire (Cira Mandatory Review)

Putz Mulligan

shhhhhh, cigar learning in process!
Joined
Mar 7, 2006
Messages
1,830
2005 God of Fire Double Robusto by Carlito

Size: Double Robusto 5.75 x 52
Wrapper: Cameroon
Binder: Dominican Republic
Filler: Dominican Republic
Production: 10,000 Total Units
Smoke Time: 1 hour 35 minutes
Cutter: Xitar Punch (just kidding)
Torch: Dunhill (just kidding again)

2095115558_f265012488.jpg


I felt as I was reviewing this cigar that I was back in English class and my teacher was asking us to describe eating an orange without using comparisons, nearly impossible to say the least. Fortunately this is not one of those times. That being said I only hope I do this wonderful cigar justice.

I was one of the fortunate ones that volunteered in a thread Cira ran for mandatory review. Thanks Cira for the opportunity!

Pre-light and First Third:

This cigar was a solidly-built stick with beautiful construction and a nice oily finish with light veining.

2095115646_d8fab5e329.jpg


The filler was nice and open in the foot and felt consistently the same the entire length. I used my cheap $1.50 punch to start. There was a nice easy draw with a slight residual sweetness left on the lips. I applied the flame from my 99 cent Bic® lighter and was rewarded with lots of smoke with some highly spiced essence of cedar, apple and citrus. After it settled dark coffee overtones began to emerge with the spiciness continuing develop.

2095115798_de2e1e41d1.jpg


2095115866_3be8d1cace.jpg


Second and Concluding Thirds:
The ash was a nice light mottled grey and was evidence of a very consistent and even burn. It was a bit chilly for Southern California standards but there was fresh moisture in the air from an earlier rain so the cigar performed beautifully and unswerving with no hint of dryness.

A solid amount of smoke was in attendance during the entire experience as no binding was evident throughout. There was no hint of harshness as the flavor shifted to a nice dark chocolate with a hint of fresh grass after a new rain.

The ash fell off in the second third leaving a nice conical cherry.

2094343489_567ea779d8.jpg


With the final third coming into play I was beginning to feel the chill from sitting outside in my hooded sweatshirt but I felt I could tough it out to the very end and I was not disappointed. (This is my Turk10mm MySpace shot!)

2095115736_3d85464354.jpg


The finish was loaded with heavy cedar zest and peppery nuances. I took it down to the nub and reluctantly set it aside.

2095116218_0fba46ab88_o.jpg


I did have an interesting after taste that lingered as I was beginning to type this and the only thing I can describe it as is antiseptic. I am at a loss for this as I have never experienced it before.

In summary, I felt this cigar performed beautifully and dependably. It was satisfying to the point were I was left with just a hint of wanting more. All in all a wonderful smoke and I would recommend it to anyone.
 
Nice pictures and good review. In your opinion, was the cigar worth the price? The price is the one reason I probably will never try one.
 
Nice review and pics Charlie. :thumbs: I prefer the Carlito over the Don Carlos myself.

As far as the "Are they worth it" question........... I love these cigars. I will gladly fork out the money when I can afford it.

At the same time, I don't pass judgement on someone who thinks they are not "twenty five dollars good."
 
Nice review Charlie :thumbs:

I think you should do more reviews, as you are good at it. Definitely got a sense of how this cigar would be. I've been sitting on a 2005 GoF Carlito Churchill waiting for a special occassion. Now, I might have to move it up in my schedule!

Cheers,
antaean
 
Very nice review and pics Charlie.

These are nice smokes!

Brian
 
Nice pictures and good review. In your opinion, was the cigar worth the price? The price is the one reason I probably will never try one.

Glad you liked it.

Yes, the smoke is worth the price IMHO.
 
Nice review and pics Charlie, looks like it might be time to fire one up. :thumbs:
 
In my opinion the Carlito GOFs are the best cigars out there. They are always spot on in flavor and construction. I don't hesitate at all to pay retail for these. I wouldn't pay more than MSRP +tax as they aren't that hard to find.

There is always room for a box of these in my humi.
 
Awesome review. I love hearing what others think of one of my favorite smokes.
 
How do you not get flavors of flint and nasty lighter fumes when lighting a $25 cigar with a bic?
 
How do you not get flavors of flint and nasty lighter fumes when lighting a $25 cigar with a bic?

Because it's a Bic not a Zippo! Sheesh! :sign:

Of course, I am open to receiving a nice torch if you have one handy! ;)
 
In my opinion the Carlito GOFs are the best cigars out there. They are always spot on in flavor and construction. I don't hesitate at all to pay retail for these. I wouldn't pay more than MSRP +tax as they aren't that hard to find.

There is always room for a box of these in my humi.


Thanks for the great review Putz!!!


I agree fully with LilBastage. Lots of people have said that these are over-priced, underperforming, and overall disappointing cigars, but I really really like them. Always perfect burn and construction. The cameroon with Opus-esque filler is also very nice. Not has heavy-handed as an OpusX, but more aromatic and sweet. I prefer the GOF Carlito Double Robusto 2005 over Anejos and Opuses. The move to non-coffined packaging made the price slightly better.

Might be time to smoke another tonight...
 
Top