Ever Had A Cigar You Didn't Like?

[amateuraficionado]

So everyone is always talking about their favorite sticks and the ones they like the most. It occurred to me that I can't think of one cigar that I've smoked that I would not smoke again. There are some that I may not spend my money on but if gifted or received in a trade, I'd smoke any of 'em again. So how about it? Is there a cigar that you've smoked that you absolutely would not smoke again, even if it was given to you?

No machine or hand rolled. Only handmade cigars!

DeVonn

 

[sanchopanza]

I was given some perdomo from a rep that wants us to carry the line in our shop. I lit up one of the 'perdomo reserve', and made it through about a quarter of the cigar. I don't think I will ever smoke this cigar again... There's also Macanudo. I smoked one Macanudo about 5 years ago, and will never smoke another in my lifetime...

 

[MoeCizlak]

I had a Drew Estate something or other that I flat out disliked.

 

[5 O'Clock Somewhere]

Arturo Fuente Curly Head

Not a good cigar at all.

 

[cabaiguan juan]

Anything Camacho, except the Select line. I think the Camacho line sucks. I'm over RP cigars too, they were ok when i started but i dont care for them anymore.

 

[Jonesy]

I'll probably get a thrashing for this, but I just don't like the Pepin black Cuban Classics.

 

[anvil]

Every cigar from Perdomo I have smoked has been..um...shall we say "not to my liking"

 

[Dr. Marneaus]

Smoked a Patel R4 maduro that I wouldn't ever buy again. It was a good experience, I suppose, but the after affects were awful. I havn't felt that bad from smoking ever.

 

[sack]

Connies are a thing of the past for me. That was a long love affair for sure.

 

[JayBay]

I've had a few that I wouldn't go out of my way for, but very few that I'd outright refuse to smoke. I bought a few bundles of Mosaico Sumatras from Famous. The first two bundles were fanfrickintastic; the pyramid and the torpedo. The next one I got was the toro, and this bundle is pungent with ammonia. Thank goodness I've managed to give away all but a few to a few non-aficionado friends. I really don't even want them in my humi - I don't want the cooties to crawl off onto my good sticks! :0

 

[medic5888]

I dont know if it was just a bad box at the B & M but 6 of my BOTL sat down and smoked a CAO America and we all had the same opinion that we hated it. I'd be willing to give it another try.

 

[theorangeman]

Macanduo (have had two or three before and that was more than enough)
Partagas Black (actually, I haven't had a NC Partagas that I would want want to smoke again but the Blacks are just flat out awful - like smoking burnt tires)
Nat Sherman Met. (damn cigar left an aftertaste in my mouth for 2-3 days, truly)
Most Perdomos (used to be a cigar that I liked, but definitely not anymore)
Most Punch (never had a NC one that I liked)

I'm sure there are others, but that's all that comes to mind right now. I'm off to watch a movie and smoke a GOOD cigar... Tat Regios.

 

[Lightninrod]

Oh yes! I've got most of a box(bought blindly/stupidly) of Drew Estate's Isle del Sol Churchills that I can hardly bring myself to finish. They are so damn sweeeeeeeeeeeet! :blush: Anyone want to trade.... ?


Dan

 

[theorangeman]

Connies are a thing of the past for me. That was a long love affair for sure.

:laugh:

Yeah, good cheap smoke but I smoked my last one a couple of years ago and haven't had any desire to go back.

 

[gunsandcigars88]

Gurkha Shaggyfoot. It is the first and only gurkha that I will ever have. I lit it, smoked about one inch, and let the camp fire have it.
B

 

[jfields]

Smoked a fair amount of an Acid Kuba Kuba a few years back. That was one nasty taste that I could not seem to get out of my mouth. I get the willies just thinking back on it.
I can't stand just about any RYJ NC.
Smoked a Bauzra Belicoso last year in a Blind taste test.......Had to force myself to get as far as I did on it.

 

[bilder]

Anything with the name Victor Sinclair attached to it.

 

[AKmik]

I have quite a few smokes that I have tried and would not smoke again, every Torano except the reserva selecta, anything Comacho, and will probably be drawn and quartered for saying this but I really dislike the Fuente short story. If a cigar is described as "spicy" or "peppery" that is almost a sure bet I will not like it.

I guess I am pretty particular about what I like, but I do try new smokes all the time. I surely have left a lot of half burned smokes in the ashtray if the do not fit the bill.

 

[Rodrigo de Jerez]

Actually, I dislike more cigars than I like. I often enjoy the opening notes of quite a few cigars only to become very bored with them during the course of the smoke.

-Mark

 

[NMSCORPSFAN]

Quintero robusto the reblend. One of the worse tar gars that I have ever smoked. I could of patched my roof with that damn cigar. CAO America I've tasted more flavor in smog.