• Hi Guest - Sign up now for Secret Santa 2024!
    Click here to sign up!
  • Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Double Review Thursday -

denverdog

Not now chief, I’m in the F**kin zone.
Joined
Sep 13, 2006
Messages
3,347
We had a snow/ice storm yesterday which made for an aweful drive home last night so I decided that there was no need to challenge the roads and conditions and stayed home this morning. Not having had a cigar in about a week, I took full advantage of working from home today and decided to smoke a couple of sticks that I have been wanting to try for a while.


First off is a Cuesta-Rey Stanford's Cameroon Reserve Pyramid #9, special thanks to Smellysell. This is a great looking stick with an oily toothy wrapper and after reading Mark Twains review of the churchill, I was really looking forward to it. Prelight smell was earthy and a little sweet. The draw had just enough resistance and the burn nice and even needing no attention. The flavor was quite complex and although I was working while smoking it, it really impressed me. The second best part of this cigar was the sheer amount of smoke it produced. Its Padron type smoke and fills the air with even the lightest puff. The overall taste was a little on the mild side but full of character. I will definitely get my hands on more of these.

*Photo credit to Ginseng and JHolmes763. I liked the format so much I had to try it. ;)
b_175620.jpg



Next on the list was a VSG Enchantment. Being a big fan of both VSG's and this vitola, I naturally gravitate to this cigar. Initial smell hinted of all good things VSG; big tobacco and a slightly sweet taste to the cap. Prelight draw was a bit firm as I expected but it opened up nicely once lit. The burn started to go bad right off the bat and although I was able to touch it up, the cigar had issues staying lit so I relit after the first ash. I fear this may have affected the taste or I at least hope it did because I really did not care for this cigar. The taste was a bit tarry and stale and did nothing for me. It did start to come around in the very last inch but too little too late. I have had one previous to this and I remember enjoying it so take this for what it's worth.

Overall the star today was the Cuesta-Rey. For less then half the price of the Enchantment it was better in every way from appearance to taste. I will continue to smoke my VSG's although not the Enchantment. If you like the figurados, stick with a Work of Art.
b_220553.jpg
 
Glad to hear you liked the Stanford, I haven't dug into any of mine yet, but after reading this, one might burn this weekend.
 
same here, i ordered a box of the CR and planned on splitting, but kept most of them for myself :) If not, i'll def have one on Tues. before i study for my Med Chem test.
 
Nice pictures, you might want to give the Enchantment another shot in the future, the recent batch shipping out was kind of moldy and bitter - I saw mold on them at 3 different B&Ms.
 
Glad to hear you liked the Stanford, I haven't dug into any of mine yet, but after reading this, one might burn this weekend.
Thanks again brudda!

Nice pictures, you might want to give the Enchantment another shot in the future, the recent batch shipping out was kind of moldy and bitter - I saw mold on them at 3 different B&Ms.
That is interesting although this one was from an older batch I.E.; before the label change. I suspect part of the issue was the fact that it wouldn't stay lit in the beginning and I had to relight. Either way if I come across another in the future I will burn it just to see what the deal is.
 
DD, was the Cuesta from this latest shipment or does yours have some age on it?
 
I totally agree with your impression on both cigars. I had one enchantment last year and it did nothing for me. The Standford's reserve is wonderful and a steal for the price as long as it can be found. I wasn't aware that anymore were in production than the 1000-2000 boxes produced, which is a shame.

Great review, I love the pic setup and I might steal it if I get the time. :thumbs:
 
DD, was the Cuesta from this latest shipment or does yours have some age on it?
I believe this is from the latest shipment, Justin can you confirm?

I totally agree with your impression on both cigars. I had one enchantment last year and it did nothing for me. The Standford's reserve is wonderful and a steal for the price as long as it can be found. I wasn't aware that anymore were in production than the 1000-2000 boxes produced, which is a shame.

Great review, I love the pic setup and I might steal it if I get the time. :thumbs:
The enchantment was a bummer. I can't pin it on the fact that the thinner ring VSG's are better because I had a wizard that was fantastic a few weeks ago. I am worried that the Cuesta-Rey's are as limited as you say and I am definitely getting a box of each just in case.
 
This review makes me excited to try that Cuesta Rey I have in the humidor.
 
I believe this is from the latest shipment, Justin can you confirm?

I don't have the box in front of me at the moment. All I can say for sure is I got them from Holt's when MT (I think) posted that they had them.
 
Top