• Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

CPs Most Underrated Cigars

tsmckenney

tsmckenney

Mick
Joined
Mar 7, 2007
Messages
2,954
I've wanted to do this thread for a while. What cigar do you think deserves more respect, and why?


My choice: Joya de Nicaragua Celebracion Consul. This stick has a nice balance of tangy sweetness and Nicaraguan bite. It's kinda of like an Antano and a Padron 2000 mixed together. And for $13 a fiver, you just can't lose.
 
I like the Mayorga maduro robusto. For less than $40 a box, it's hard to go wrong with these.
 
Where did all the Padron Fumas go to? At $39 for 25 cigars how could you go wrong.
 
Oliva Serie G Maduro ... damn I sound like a broken record. $3
Genuine Pre Embargo Counterfeit Cubans <$2


Seth
 
Jonesy said:
I like the Mayorga maduro robusto. For less than $40 a box, it's hard to go wrong with these.
Click to expand...



Ive had the Torps and I must agree. They are pretty good and at that dollar you cant go wrong.

Damon
 
tone-ny said:
Where did all the Padron Fumas go to? At $39 for 25 cigars how could you go wrong.
Click to expand...


Padron Fumas have been discontinued.

As far as underrated I would have to say the Fonseca Serie F robusto. I used to be able to snag all the 5ers I wanted off the Devils site for $13 or less. They have recently gone to beyond what I will spend. I guess other people started figuring out how freakin good these sticks are :(
 
You just need to keep your eyes open and bid early. I got a 5'er for $11. That being said, I've only had 1 and wasn't too enthused. The smoke seemed thin and whispy and it wasn't as full-bodied as I expected.

Sancho Panza double maduro don't seem to get much love, but I like 'em. :)
 
tone-ny said:
Where did all the Padron Fumas go to? At $39 for 25 cigars how could you go wrong.
Click to expand...

You wouldn't happen to have a bundle/box you'd like to sell would ya?! :whistling: :laugh:

I miss them. They need to bring them back.

I just ordered a bundle of Tampa Sweetheart Maduros. Never had them, how are they?
 
JR's Connies... so far, haven't had a bad one, and i hear with some age, they get better.
 
Jonesy said:
I like the Mayorga maduro robusto. For less than $40 a box, it's hard to go wrong with these.
Click to expand...

Yes!
I always manage to forget about these smokes, but they are quite tasty!

I love to flog the LGC Wavell. A $3 cigar that has a lot of character and one that I prefer to the Padron 2000.

I used to love the El Rico Habano, but they haven't been as good in recent years. I never hear them mentioned on the boards.
 
Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Maduro Churchill...i'm a broken record with this cigar but i love it...my B&M sells it for about 2.50-3.00
 
St Luis Rey is the most underated - boxes for $50 and one of the tastiest NC cigars I have ever had when stored properly.
 
Maria Mancini De Gaulle

Carlos Torano Signature
 
Another vote for the Mayorga Maduro - Toro size. Just damn tasty for $2-2.50 a stick.

Also, if you smoke 'em young, the Sancho Panza Double Maduro are mighty tasty.

Pushing it a bit is the Camacho Negro. I think these are $3-4 a stick but they are a different beast from the rest of the Camacho lines. Very flavorful and plenty of oomph for the money.

Montecristo Peruvian Fer de Lance. A small stick but packed with muscle.

Wilkey
 
I'll second the motion on the consuegras--always good but an occsional tight one.
Picked up a box of Perdomo "The cigar" coronas, very good for the price.
 
I honestly think hands down profile/strength vs price its the Punch Gran Puro, you can get them retail at ~$3 a stick or pretty regularly off cbid at $2 a stick.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top