• Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Cigar Aficionado COTY and Top 25

What a piece of shit list that is... There isn't a Rocky Patel, NC Montecrisco, Oliva or NC Partagas made that is better than a Cuban Cohiba or a Don Carlos. Brickhouse at 10?? La Finka's are better than that stick... I wouldn't even use this list as toilet paper if it was printed out.

But everyone has their own tastes!!
 
CBoukal said:
What a piece of shit list that is... There isn't a Rocky Patel, NC Montecrisco, Oliva or NC Partagas made that is better than a Cuban Cohiba or a Don Carlos. Brickhouse at 10?? La Finka's are better than that stick... I wouldn't even use this list as toilet paper if it was printed out.

But everyone has their own tastes!!
Click to expand...

Indeed. Three Havana cigars? Their ratings have always been laughable.
 
CBoukal said:
What a piece of shit list that is... There isn't a Rocky Patel, NC Montecrisco, Oliva or NC Partagas made that is better than a Cuban Cohiba or a Don Carlos. Brickhouse at 10?? La Finka's are better than that stick... I wouldn't even use this list as toilet paper if it was printed out.

But everyone has their own tastes!!
Click to expand...
Ridiculous, Chad. You know damn well you’d pick that RP Conviction and love it before you told tall tales about how “good” that Cohiba Maduro is.
 
Top 28 cigars for 2024 according to JoeMO. Cigars with the same score are listed alphabetically. I did not receive any money from any brand. (that's a joke)

Viaje Private Keep Lemon (Dan) 4/18/24 97
God of Fire (from Todd ) 8/4/24 97

El Septimo Michelangelo (Cigar Chateau, Wich, KS) 8/28/24 96

Big Sky Bighorn 2.0 11/22/24 95
CH Mil Dias Edicion Limitada 2021 (Santino’s) 9/24/24 95
DTT Todas Las Dias 8/20/24 95
Fiero Tego Timeless (Just4Him, Springfield, MO) 8/29/24 95
Foundation Aksum (Gran Cru) 6/16/24 95
Foundation Olmec 8/20/24 95
Foundation The Tabernacle 10/21/24 95
Luciano Foreign Affair 11/14/24 95
Rojas Unfinished Business 6/20/24 95
Tatuaje Cojona 2012 White Ecuador Sumatra 8/31/24 95
-Cigar Chateau, Wich, KS

CAO Amazon Basin (Todd) 9/22/24 94
CH Las Calaveras 2020 (GC) 10/19/24 94
Crowned Heads, La Imperiosa (Todd) 4/7/24 94
DTT Red Meat Lovers (Ben) 1/16/24 94
Espinosa Murciélago 3/12/24 94
HVC Black Friday 2022 (Dan L. 3 pink) 7/15/24 94
HVC Black Friday 2023 (Dan L. 3 pink) 12/12/24 94+
Illusione Cruzado 6/19/24 94
Illusione Corojo 8/12/24 94
Luciano The Dreamer 9/13/24 94
My Father La Promesa 6/2/24 94
Tatuaje Drac 3/26, 6/12 94
Tatuaje Reserva 10/8/24 94
Tatuaje 20th 4/19/24 94
Viaje Zombie Antidote 7/17/24 94
 
Last edited:
JoeMO said:
Top 28 cigars for 2024 according to JoeMO. Cigars with the same score are listed alphabetically. I did not receive any money from any brand. (that's a joke)

Viaje Private Keep Lemon (Dan) 4/18/24 97
God of Fire (from Todd ) 8/4/24 97

El Septimo Michelangelo (Cigar Chateau, Wich, KS) 8/28/24 96

Big Sky Bighorn 2.0 11/22/24 95
CH Mil Dias Edicion Limitada 2021 (Santino’s) 9/24/24 95
DTT Todas Las Dias 8/20/24 95
Fiero Tego Timeless (Just4Him, Springfield, MO) 8/29/24 95
Foundation Aksum (Gran Cru) 6/16/24 95
Foundation Olmec 8/20/24 95
Foundation The Tabernacle 10/21/24 95
Luciano Foreign Affair 11/14/24 95
Rojas Unfinished Business 6/20/24 95
Tatuaje Cojona 2012 White Ecuador Sumatra 8/31/24 95
-Cigar Chateau, Wich, KS

CAO Amazon Basin (Todd) 9/22/24 94
CH Las Calaveras 2020 (GC) 10/19/24 94
Crowned Heads, La Imperiosa (Todd) 4/7/24 94
DTT Red Meat Lovers (Ben) 1/16/24 94
Espinosa Murciélago 3/12/24 94
HVC Black Friday 2022 (Dan L. 3 pink) 7/15/24 94
HVC Black Friday 2023 (Dan L. 3 pink) 12/12/24 94+
Illusione Cruzado 6/19/24 94
Illusione Corojo 8/12/24 94
Luciano The Dreamer 9/13/24 94
My Father La Promesa 6/2/24 94
Tatuaje Drac 3/26, 6/12 94
Tatuaje Reserva 10/8/24 94
Tatuaje 20th 4/19/24 94
Viaje Zombie Antidote 7/17/24 94
Click to expand...
August was a good month! 👍
 
CBoukal said:
What a piece of shit list that is... There isn't a Rocky Patel, NC Montecrisco, Oliva or NC Partagas made that is better than a Cuban Cohiba or a Don Carlos. Brickhouse at 10?? La Finka's are better than that stick... I wouldn't even use this list as toilet paper if it was printed out.

But everyone has their own tastes!!
Click to expand...

I am glad we feel the same way!
 
JoeMO said:
Top 28 cigars for 2024 according to JoeMO. Cigars with the same score are listed alphabetically. I did not receive any money from any brand. (that's a joke)

Viaje Private Keep Lemon (Dan) 4/18/24 97
God of Fire (from Todd ) 8/4/24 97

El Septimo Michelangelo (Cigar Chateau, Wich, KS) 8/28/24 96

Big Sky Bighorn 2.0 11/22/24 95
CH Mil Dias Edicion Limitada 2021 (Santino’s) 9/24/24 95
DTT Todas Las Dias 8/20/24 95
Fiero Tego Timeless (Just4Him, Springfield, MO) 8/29/24 95
Foundation Aksum (Gran Cru) 6/16/24 95
Foundation Olmec 8/20/24 95
Foundation The Tabernacle 10/21/24 95
Luciano Foreign Affair 11/14/24 95
Rojas Unfinished Business 6/20/24 95
Tatuaje Cojona 2012 White Ecuador Sumatra 8/31/24 95
-Cigar Chateau, Wich, KS

CAO Amazon Basin (Todd) 9/22/24 94
CH Las Calaveras 2020 (GC) 10/19/24 94
Crowned Heads, La Imperiosa (Todd) 4/7/24 94
DTT Red Meat Lovers (Ben) 1/16/24 94
Espinosa Murciélago 3/12/24 94
HVC Black Friday 2022 (Dan L. 3 pink) 7/15/24 94
HVC Black Friday 2023 (Dan L. 3 pink) 12/12/24 94+
Illusione Cruzado 6/19/24 94
Illusione Corojo 8/12/24 94
Luciano The Dreamer 9/13/24 94
My Father La Promesa 6/2/24 94
Tatuaje Drac 3/26, 6/12 94
Tatuaje Reserva 10/8/24 94
Tatuaje 20th 4/19/24 94
Viaje Zombie Antidote 7/17/24 94
Click to expand...

I vote for Joe’s List!
 
Another year. Same result. Ads = ratings. I see this thread come up around this time for the last 10 years. Same responses That’s why I have decided a while back to buy 5ers of every new release that catches my attention and is priced reasonably. Tried many great cigars learned new things etc. guess what was one of the things I learned. …. Cubans are not the only cigars where production year affects how good the same cigar is. Outside of Padrons and maybe a handful of other particular cigars taste quality will vary from batch to batch. So even if CA scored the cigars correctly it does not mean shit unless we know the exact year of production
 
I guess I am smoking shitty cigars. I may have smoked two or three of those on the list.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top