Atucks Vintage/Rare Cigar Reviews

[atuck]

At the request of others. I decided to include a compilation of my Vintage cigar reviews in one thread. These pretty much are reviews that only address the cigars themselves rather than the experiences that surround the smoking of them. With a few exceptions of course.

I will keep adding more as they come. I will 1st post in the regular review section then archive them here for future reference.

I'm glad some of you enjoy these as I enjoy doing them.

1993 Partagas Serie du Connaisseur No. 3

1993 Partagas Charlottes, Nice Partagas flavor!

Pre-Embargo Henry Clay Diamontino, from either 40's or 50's

Cuban Davidoff #2

1998 H. UPMANN MONARCH from newly opened box

1970's RyJ Corona, Watch me open a sealed box!

1997 Montecristo Especial No. 1, 10 yr old perfection!

1950's Bering Admiral (Ever wonder what those old American Candela, Cedar lined tin chest, pics and review - amazing cigar

Pre-Embargo Henry Clay Non Plus Ultra Coquetas, A nice little rarity that packs a punch!

1980's Davidoff Dom Perignon, Perfect Easter Cigar!

1980's La Escepcion de Jose Gener - Longo, A very interesting Vintage Cigar

NUB to the Extreme -- another Henry Clay Diamontino, You all told me I should use a rouch clip!

OR Anejo 55 - Absolutely Wonderful!, Thanks Rod!!!

DON CARLOS EDICION de ANIVERSARIO, Double Robusto -- for Moki

And here is a link to the build of my Walk-In Humidor:

Project Walk-In, IT'S DONE!!! - Updated pics added 12/3/06

 

[Ginseng]

This is a classic and well worth a sticky. :thumbs:

Wilkey

 

[jfields]

I am glad you do these Alan. I use these regularly reading and, rereading them. This will make it easier that doing individual searches.
John

 

[cuppajack]

This is great!

Saw a couple of reviews that I had missed.

Can this get a sticky please?

 

[Infinity]

Absolutely classic. I agree with Wilkey but only if you send me some of the older smokes to concur with your findings. :blush:


Brian

 

[smokelaw1]

Outstanding! Thanks for putting these all together!

 

[OpusXKC]

These are great reviews and reference. I guess the old adage is true, "Smokem' if you've gotem'" Well worth the status of being a sticky.

 

[cigarsmkr]

all i have to say is wow!
good job

 

[Saxjazzman]

These are great reviews and reference. I guess the old adage is true, "Smokem' if you've gotem'" Well worth the status of being a sticky.

Ditto on this being a sticky. It is a great reference for those who may want to try to walk in your footsteps. The pictures and advice here can save a lot of headaches and pave the way for BOTLs /SOTLs wanting to do the same thing. May you enjoy it for many years!! :thumbs:

 

[CigarStone]

Absolutely classic. I agree with Wilkey but only if you send me some of the older smokes to concur with your findings. :blush:


Brian

X2

I might be a good idea........that way we could compare a newbie's perspective to yours :whistling:

 

[BobbyRitz]

Great idea Alan. These are some of the best reviews on this site IMHO.

Rob

 

[moki]

Where's the Don Carlos 30th review? That's a damn fine smoke!

 

[atuck]

Where's the Don Carlos 30th review? That's a damn fine smoke!

ADDED! Agreed that it is a "damn fine smoke!". Eventually I will do another review on one that is more detailed and edit the original one. This cigar certainly deserves the attention. :thumbs:

 

[MiamiCubano]

Very nice Alan...keep 'em coming! :thumbs: