• Hi Guest - Sign up now for Secret Santa 2024!
    Click here to sign up!
  • Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Acid Review

Dan66

New Member
Joined
Jul 1, 2006
Messages
152
Like most everyone here, I've really been getting a kick out of the Acid Review thread in this section. In the past I've enjoyed a Drew Estate Java now and again, but never had an interest in the far out Acids. The humorous reviews just kind of solidified that. But I was approached by a BOTL here on the forum and asked for my honest opinion. I was sent several sticks of a couple different Acid lines, so I dove right in.

Let me set the stage for a moment first. I've been smoking cigars on and off for the better part of 20 years. I've never been a brand snob of any sort though - largely because I didn't bother to educate myself very much. But with the advent of the internet, information abounds. I know more about cigars now than ever before. And believe it or not, I tend to favor the less expensive stuff. Toranos are my flavor-of-the-day lately. You know - your basic $4 a stick smokes. I say this because I want everyone to know that my pallete isn't as refined as many are. I'm not sure I'd know an ISOM if it snuck up and bit me. My taste is kinda the every man taste. I'm not entirely oposed to a flavored cigar every now and then; although I typically prefer a nice medium tobbaco with a decent tobbaco taste. There... I'm a regualr guy with regular tastes.

Alrighty then... the first Acid I tried was called the Liquid.

Upon removing it from the celo, I'm met with a unique spicy aroma. Not entirely different from walking through the men's cologne section of Macy's. Not bad at all; just unexpected for a cigar. It was then I realized I should put aside my typical cigar expectations.

The construction was really top notch. Tightly rolled, but with a perfect draw. On a side note: these bands come off easier than any I've ever removed. You don't need to worry about tearing the wrapper with your fingernail. Initially the "fragrance" was a bit overwhelming. I didn't detect a sweetened tip as some do with the Acids. The first inch or so had a distinct cinnamon taste. Not too strong, but it was there. The smoke however, was very clove-like. It was odd though... There wasn't much of a clove taste.

After the cinnamon faded, I was left with a quite pleasant tobbaco flavor. The taste of tobbaco but the smell of clove in the air was really very nice. I've had three of these so far and I've gotta say that I've enjoyed each more than the one before. Each time I had only water to drink with it. You won't want anything with a very strong flavor of its own.

This is not an everyday cigar. But niether is an Opus X. It's a very nice change of pace and I plan to make it part of my rotation - y'know, when I can afford one.
 
Yikes! I can't imagine smoking but one of those. You're right on about the easy-off bands though. Perhaps the tip on this one was not sweetened. If it were, it'd be hard to miss.

Thanks for sharing your perspective on this controversial cigar.

Wilkey
 
Yikes! I can't imagine smoking but one of those. You're right on about the easy-off bands though. Perhaps the tip on this one was not sweetened. If it were, it'd be hard to miss.

Thanks for sharing your perspective on this controversial cigar.

Wilkey
That's just the thing... Don't expect it to taste like you favorite smoke - it won't! Enjoy it instead like you would a cup of piping hot tea. If you go into it with that kind of mindset, it makes all the difference in the world.
 
So far all of the reviews on these Acid's have been fun reads, this time however, i'd actually consider trying one myself! Great review Dan.
 
:laugh: had i not had an acid before, i would have possibly tried it after this read just for giggles.
 
Yikes! I can't imagine smoking but one of those. You're right on about the easy-off bands though. Perhaps the tip on this one was not sweetened. If it were, it'd be hard to miss.

Thanks for sharing your perspective on this controversial cigar.

Wilkey
That's just the thing... Don't expect it to taste like your favorite smoke - it won't! Enjoy it instead like you would a cup of piping hot tea. If you go into it with that kind of mindset, it makes all the difference in the world.

Dan, That is a great way to put it.

I suggest to people not to compare an Acid to their favorite cigars because there is no comparison. It is not a fair comparison because the Acids are prepared a little differently than most cigars that we smoke. I tell people to smoke and attempt to enjoy it for what it is.

For someone to give it a fair chance, they have to smoke an Acid without any expectations, or preconceived notions. You have to smoke it with an open mind, otherwise there is no chance that you will be able to enjoy it for what it has to offer. :thumbs:
 
I suggest to people not to compare an Acid to their favorite cigars because there is no comparison. It is not a fair comparison because the Acids are prepared a little differently than most cigars that we smoke. I tell people to smoke and attempt to enjoy it for what it is.

For someone to give it a fair chance, they have to smoke an Acid without any expectations, or preconceived notions. You have to smoke it with an open mind, otherwise there is no chance that you will be able to enjoy it for what it has to offer. :thumbs:
Yep, that's the thing: don't hope that it will taste as "good as your favorite cigar." It's different than your everyday smoke just as say blackened catfish may be from your typical dinner rotation. It's really good and not something you have every night.

Another Drew Estate that I'd like to comment on is the Natural "Root."

This one didn't take any getting used to. From the very begining, it reminded me of a pipe. If I closed my eyes I swore I was in some 200 year old lodge somewhere in Europe. Unfortunately, when I opened my eyes all I saw was my transmission leak and a collection of rusty garden tools.

The construction here was as clean as the nicest cigars I've ever smoked. Perfect, even burn all the way down. A nice slow cool burn leaving all the ash you'd want. This was one of those rare smokes that I like to enjoy with the garage door closed. Similar to the Acid, the smell of the smoke was half the fun. I didn't want to let it escape too quickly. With one I had water and with another I enjoyed a few fingers of Amaritto. A nice sweet compliment for such a dessert cigar.

I can openly recommend this this stick to anyone that enjoys a sweet licquer or pipe tobbaco. I'm looking forward to having many more of these.
 
The Root is one I have tried and found interesting. If they weren't so expensive, I might dabble in a few of the aromatics. But they really aren't my cup o' tea.

Thank for the review! :thumbs:
 
Alright everybody, I've got one more Acid to add to my review thread...

This one is called "Wafe." It's about the size (and shape and thickness) of a couple sticks of Juicy Fruit stuck together. Rather odd. I'm not quite sure how to hold it, and I'm not sure what the point of it is. Then there's cutting it. Hmmm... Can't use any type of standard cutter (that I know of). Luckily, my profession and various hobbies dictate that I have a multitude of X-Acto knives laying about. So I slice a hole in the cap.

The pre-light draw is pretty sweet. I believe this tip has indeed been dipped in something. But it's not an altogether bad sweetness. I kinda liked it. Upon lighting, it became apparent there was no real need to rotate. I mean, it's so flat that it ignites right away.

After that, it proved as consistent and even as any other Drew Estate. Love 'em or hate 'em, you've got to hand it to them in the quality department. Being as small as they are, they don't take very long to smoke at all. 25 maybe 35 minutes. Long enough to make it through an automotive magazine. The taste was again, very unique. But in a good way.

As I said about the other Acid: it's not your father's Oldsmobile. Don't expect it to drive like one. It's an entirely different kind of smoke that I liken to a cup of tea. There is an abundance of clove in the smell, but not so much in the taste. I want to say I detected a bit of coconut; but maybe not. I was like trying to nail down the ingredients in a tropical drink. They're multi-faceted to say the least. Far from single-dimensional. Plenty of smoke, too. The ash wouldn't really accumulate (to any length) due to the thinness of the stick. As I made my way through it, I found myself sort of involunarily squeezing it into a round shape. But of course this opened up the draw too much. Since that was my doing, I won't hold it against the cigar.

In summary, I have to say I quite enjoyed these. I found the flat shape a little offputting. (When I smoke a cigar I want it to look like I'm smoking a cigar.) I wish it had been perhaps a robusto; but DE has this knack of making a specific blend available in only one shape. Perhaps a larger ring size would have been over-powering. I'd say give this one a try. And not only one. Grab 2 or 3 and don't be close-minded. Wait until you've had all of them, and you may just be surprised!
 
Top