• Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

favorite all time cigar

Gator

Gator

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2005
Messages
2,418
Location
Asheville NC
So far, mine is a Opus robusto, love the taste, construction, strength. 2nd right now is DC Max robusto, but still have 1926 Padron #2 maddie to smoke, as well as a GOF and Forbidden X. No experience w/ the top shelf isoms, but i'm sure they'd be in the top 5 based on some of the few isoms i've smoked
 
I agree is Bill, I've enjoyed so many... the setting makes a big difference also.
 
Still haven't had an ISOM since I got "serious" about cigars a few years ago. But being the simple man I am (read: cheap), I always look forward to a Toranos Exodus Gold and 1916 Cameroon. Relatively inexpensive and great tastes.
 
For me its gotta be a VSG they never seem to dissapoint. It doesnt even matter what size. Which reminds me I should stock up soon.

D
 
Very hard question, too hard actually....but I know a few that are up there:

In no particular order:

LFD Double Ligero Lancero
Tatuaje RC 184
Bolivar Belicoso Fino
Black Banded Forbidden X (Tubed)
Anejo 50
 
I've had many fabulous cigars, but several sticks really come to mind as being truly awesome smokes:

02 Tang Comissioned Upmann Monarchs
95 OR Opus X Reserva d'Chateau
AF Destino al Siglo 13
01 Punch Punch (never was able to replicate this cigar with other Punch Punches)
97 RG PC

I hope to have many more memorable cigars in the future.

edited for typo.
 
My all time fav for a cigar I can actually get is the Hemingway Signature. Always consistent, always available, always affordable, and always a perfect match for my tastebuds.


According to me (LOL) the best cigar I have ever smoked and the one I would, if I was able, go back in time and buy every one that was ever made was the Padron Millenium.
 
I'd have to say DC Maximus Toro, or an Ashton VSG Spellbound (I think it was, it was definately a big sucker). That being said, I did have a Partagas EL 2006 Ser D in Cuba in November that was simply spectacular. I went on a mission to get a box to bring back, but could only find 1 more cigar, and that's resting in the depths of my humidor waiting for a special occasion.
 
My one cigar, though impossible for me to get, has to be the Trinidad Robusto Extra. It has been three years since I had one, bu I can still smell and taste it. Some times when I see a review for it my heart does that wierd beat skip :blush: .

Who am I kidding, nothing beats a 2 week old white owl fresh from the gas station :D .

Billy
 
Had this thread back in January of last year and just slightly different here. I haven't changed my mind yet.
 
Not sure if I could go just one smoke, but a couple come to mind

Morales Custom Rolled
Davidoff #2 1983
Opus X Forbidden X
Johnny-O custom

Brandon
 
I agree with many of the other guys in that it's very challenging to narrow it down to one cigar. As far as NC's go, my first experience with a Padron 40th Anni a couple of months ago (on Thanksgiving) was absolutely terrific! I look forward to smoking more of these, but at the price, it will definitely need to be a special occasion cigar.
 
List too long, too many cigars with too many characterisitics that make each my favorite cigars.

Tatuaje (all of them)
Anejo (all of them)
PAM (all sizes)
LFD Mysterio
Excalibur #1
Punch Rare Corojo
Monte #4
The list goes on.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top